Table of Contents
Title Page
Copyright Page
PREFACE
Strategy
Foreclosures
Sellers Are the New Bankers
Success Buying or Selling
Win Going In
No Doubt Getting Out
Auctioning Your Property for Top Dollar
A New Technique
Cash and Cash Flow Is King
Example
Introduction
Our Philosophy
Investing in Real Estate = High Net Worth
How to Read This Book
PART ONE
CHAPTER 1 - The Real Estate Market Has Crashed
Financial Derivatives Have Crashed the Real Estate Market
Adjustable Rate Mortgages
Savings and Loan Crisis
Acting Locally and Globally
Wall Street Took over Main Street
AIG (American International Group)
Financial Derivatives Are the Solution
Example
Lenders Use Derivatives Locally not Globally
$20 Trillion Housing Market
History
Fannie Mae
Today
The Impasse
New Programs
Homeowner Stability Initiative
Two Questions
CHAPTER 2 - Make Money Investing in a Crashed Real Estate Market
Quick Cash Strategy
Top 10 Advantages of the Quick Cash Strategy
Long-Term Wealth Building Strategy
Top 10 Advantages of Long-Term Wealth Building
Best Arena to Make Money
CHAPTER 3 - Foreclosures, Foreclosures, and Foreclosures
Foreclosure
Wholesale Real Estate
Real Estate Lenders
Wholesale Interest
Wholesale Loans
Types of Foreclosure
Judicial Foreclosure and Sale
Insured Conventional Mortgage Foreclosure
FHA Insured Mortgage Foreclosure
VA Guaranteed Mortgage Foreclosure
Second Mortgage Foreclosure
Deficiency Judgments
Lender Adjustments
CHAPTER 4 - The New Foreclosure Tactics
Short-Sales
The Short-Sale Checklist
Your Short-Sale Proposal Letter
Signed Borrower Authorization to Release Information
Borrower’s Signed Short-Sale Payoff Application
Owner Hardship Letter
Owner Financial Statement
Owner Financial History
Owner Payroll Stubs
Two Years of Owner Tax Returns
Six Months of Owner Bank Statements
Owner Credit Reports
Unemployment Benefits or Status
Medical Hardship
Divorce Decree
Signed Owner/Borrower Short-Sale Purchase Contract
Market Comparables
HUD 1 Closing Statement (or Appropriate Form for Your Country)
Repair Cost Estimates
As-Is Pictures
CHAPTER 5 - Inside the Loss Mitigation Department
12 Short-Sale Lender Factors
Number of Lender Nonperforming Loans
Lender Financial Condition
Third-Party Investor’s Financial Condition
Third-Party Investor’s Loss Mitigation Department
Freddie Mac Short-Sale
Servicing Lenders
Borrower’s Finances
Mortgage Insurance
As-Is Value of Property
Costs to Repair Property for Resale
Repaired Value
Cost of Securing and Maintaining Property
Cost of Holding and Selling Property
CHAPTER 6 - Your Short-Sale Offer
Writing Your Short-Sale Offer
Statute of Frauds
Requirements of a Valid Contract
Types of Real Estate Contracts
Presenting Your Offer
Building Rapport
Where to Present Your Offer
When to Present Your Offer
How to Present Your Offer
Three Responses
You Must Make Money
CHAPTER 7 - Presenting Your Short-Sale Offer and Closing the Transaction
Negotiating with the Lender
Our Offer
Our Profit
The Nine Steps to a Successful Short-Sale
Closing Your Short-Sale Deal
Escrow
Title Insurance
CHAPTER 8 - Buying the Mortgage in Foreclosure
Real Estate Paperwork
Title Side
Financing Side
Security Side
What It All Means
Negotiating with the Lender
Preparation
Three Ways to Make Money
PART TWO
CHAPTER 9 - Sellers Are the New Bankers
Being the Banker
Buyer Defaults
Total Net Return
Second Mortgage
Nothing Down
Our Profit from Chapter 7
Our Deal
Rule of 72
CHAPTER 10 - Win Going In
Tying Up a Property
Retail Buyer Mind-Set
Buy the Property First, then Get the Financing or Buyer
Wholesale Buyers
Negotiating with the Owner’s Lender
Negotiating after You Put the Agreement Together
Talking to the Lender
CHAPTER 11 - No Doubt Getting Out
When to Flip
Flipping before You Write the Offer
Nondisclosure and Noncircumvention Agreement
Flipping after You Write the Offer
Flipping without Owning
Flipping before You Close Escrow
Finding a New Buyer
Flipping after You Close Escrow
Timeline for Flipping
Flipping Your Short-Sales
New Lending Laws
Other Creative Agreements
Lease
Option
Lease Purchase Agreements
Sale Leaseback Agreement
Lease Option
Reverse Lease Option (Sale Leaseback with Option to Purchase)
Purchase Option
CHAPTER 12 - Auctioning Your Property for Top Dollar
Traditional Selling
No or Low Offers
Auction Scenario
Buyer Compression
Auctioning
Auction Components
Who Conducts Your Auction?
Bidders
Advertising Your Auction
Fun
CHAPTER 13 - Types of Auctions
Types of Auctions
Foreclosure/Weekend/Absolute
Reserve Bid/Spot Bid/Dutch
Sealed Bid/Sotheby’s/Internet
Other Types of Auctions
Picking an Auction
Vanilla Auction
Chocolate Auction
Strawberry Auction
Auction Team
Auctioneer
Bidders’ Buddy
Money Magnate
Preparations Pasha
Who Should Do What?
Preparing Your Property for Auction
Repairs
Staging
CHAPTER 14 - The Who, When, and How of Your Auction
Retail Buyers Buying at Your Auction
What Retail Buyers Say They Can Afford
The Buying of Homes Is Ultimately Controlled by Emotions
Showing Your Property
Best Days/Best Time
How to Conduct Your Auction
Auction Precautions
CHAPTER 15 - Buy Low and Sell Lower
Buy Low and Sell High
Bidding War
Buy Low and Sell Lower
Make Money on the Terms
The Deal
How Did We Do?
Total Received
CHAPTER 16 - Cash and Cash Flow Is King
Cash and Cash Flow without Owning Real Estate
Assigning Real Estate Contracts
What Is Assigning?
Assignment Fees
How to Assign a Contract
Assignment Contract
Why Use an Assignment?
Assigning Makes You Money without Owning Property
Assigning Is the Fastest Way to Flip Property
Assigning Is the Quickest Way to Make Cash and Cash Flow
Assigning Avoids the Pitfalls of Real Estate Ownership
When to Assign a Contract
Option Contracts
Optionor/Optionee
Option Fee
Walt Disney
Option Advantage
How to Option
Purchase Contracts
Option Contracts
CHAPTER 17 - The Future of the Real Estate Market
CPR
New Paradigm
Inflation: The Oxygen of the Global Economy
What Is Inflation?
Protect Yourself from Inflation
Conclusion
INDEX
PREFACE
Welcome to the greatest real estate money-making opportunity of our lifetime.The real estate market has crashed. For the bold and savvy real estate investor, now is the time to buy. Buy as much real estate as you can as quickly as you can and consider financing the sale as the banker for quick cash and cash flow or holding the property for cash flow and future cash profit.You will become a multimillionaire if you do.
The United States government is proposing to pump $9.7 trillion into the economy over the next four years according to the New York Post (February 10, 2009). One trillion dollars will be in the form of an economic stimulus. Three trillion dollars will be in the form of lending and spending programs.Another $5.7 trillion will be in the form of agreements to provide loan guarantees or aid to various entities at home and abroad.
How many trillions will go directly into the real estate and mortgage markets has yet to be seen. The indirect impact of all this government spending on the real estate market is huge. Real estate prices will be going back up. Inflation, not deflation, is in the pipeline.
Strategy
You must have a strategy in order to make money investing in a crashing real estate market. Some investors use a quick cash strategy to buy and flip properties immediately. Some investors use a long-term wealth building strategy to generate cash flow and hold properties for future appreciation.We recommend you use both strategies.We will show you the pros and cons of each.
Foreclosures
Twelve million foreclosures are predicted to occur in the next four years. In Part One of The All-New Real Estate Foreclosure, Short-Selling, Underwater, Property Auction, Positive Cash Flow Book we present the all-new investment tactics needed to take advantage of this foreclosure bonanza. These new tactics include coupling short-selling and auctioning with the government bailout of the residential real estate mortgage and housing industry.
We will show you why it is in your best interest to stop buying foreclosures at the white elephant sales (the courthouse steps).We will take you inside lender loss mitigation departments and show you the 12 factors that a lender will consider before accepting your short-sale offer. We will also show you how to buy the mortgage in foreclosure from the lender at a short-sale discount.
Sellers Are the New Bankers
In Part Two we present what you must do over the next four years to become a multimillionaire investing in real estate. This starts with understanding that in a crashing real estate market, sellers are the new bankers for real estate investors.
The passage of new U.S. federal lending laws restricts easy access to new mortgage financing for all real estate buyers, especially investors. Lenders will want to verify everything about a potential borrower including job stability, monthly income and expenses, credit history, financial strength, and ability to make mortgage payments.
If you have a down payment and you have to obtain a new loan from a bank for the balance of the purchase price, unless you have perfect credit, you will not get financing. Investor buyers will have to have cash or look to the seller as banker in order to finance their real estate deals.
Success Buying or Selling
Your real estate investing success in a crashing real estate market will be determined by two factors. Buying successfully is the first factor. We call this Win Going In. Selling successfully is the second factor. We call this No Doubt Getting Out.
Win Going In
Again, without perfect credit, the only loans available to investors will be offered by sellers.We will show you how to negotiate with the seller so that the seller will jump at the opportunity to be the banker and sell you his property.You will Win Going In because you have negotiated the right price and the right terms. By buying for the right price and the right terms, you can make money when you sell.
No Doubt Getting Out
You will have No Doubt Getting Out because when you sell, you will sell for the right terms and the right price. By employing seller as banker financing when you sell you will generate cash and positive cash flow carrying the mortgage for your buyers.
Auctioning Your Property for Top Dollar
We show you how to auction your property for top dollar. By using an auction you will receive the highest price possible in a crashing market. We are not talking about a foreclosure auction where the opening bid starts low and you hope buyers bid up the price.We are talking about a version of a Dutch auction where the opening bid starts high and whoever makes the first bid below the opening bid gets the property.
A New Technique
We present a new technique that successful real estate investors can add to their repertoire to make money investing in a crashing market. This technique is Buy Low and Sell Lower. Using our experience buying and selling we answer two important questions. How does this technique work? How do you make money using this technique?
Cash and Cash Flow Is King
In normal real estate markets cash is king.This means that if you can pay cash for real estate you typically can get a lower price and therefore a better buy.
Example
Let’s look at an example. A seller is asking $1,000,000 for his New York City condo. In a normal real estate market you, as the buyer, would be concerned with how are you going to come up with the $1,000,000 asking price. If you had $900,000 to $950,000 in cash, you could negotiate a good price with the seller. In a crashing market, the seller may accept $900,000 or less if you have cash.
Cash Price Savings
In a crashing real estate market cash and cash flow is king.You must create cash and positive cash flow on every one of your deals. Otherwise you will go broke.We show you how to make a profit, create a positive cash flow, and stay in the game as a successful real estate investor.
The All-New Real Estate Foreclosure, Short-Selling, Underwater, Property Auction, Positive Cash Flow Book is the only book that shows you how to start with little or no knowledge about investing in real estate and jump in and make money in a crashing market.While everyone else is standing on the sidelines afraid to act, you will be winning the real estate investing game.
When we developed and produced the Foreclosure Training for Robert Allen, our students in Baltimore and Los Angeles were able to put into practice our insider knowledge and make money investing in foreclosures immediately. With The All-New Real Estate Foreclosure, Short-Selling, Underwater, Property Auction, Positive Cash Flow Book, you will be able to do what our students did coast to coast and beyond.
INTRODUCTION
Over the years, we have traveled throughout the world teaching various financial, real estate, success, and trust educational programs through Howell Carey International University (HCIU). We are always striving to be on the leading edge for ourselves and our students. Our investor, brokerage, trustee, and educators experience in the real estate industry lets us give you the practical knowledge and know-how we have acquired to apply to your real estate investing.
Regarding real estate education, we have taught everything from buying and selling it creatively as an individual or investor to core classes for licensing and passing real estate broker’s exams. Recently we have co-authored a university course book on real estate principles and a book directed at real estate agents helping them work professionally with buyers and investors.
We have written four books currently available that we recommend you read to give you a broader background and more in-depth training to be more effective in your real estate investing in this crashing market. These include Quick Cash in Foreclosures (2004), Make Money in Real Estate Tax Liens (2005), Make Money in Short-Sale Foreclosures (2006), and Make Money in Abandoned Properties (2006). These books are all published by John Wiley & Sons. If you feel like a total newbie and have no money at all you could study and profit from our book New Path to Real Estate Wealth, Earning Without Owning (2003).To further help you sell your properties we have a best seller currently available from John Wiley & Sons: How To Sell Your Home Without a Broker, Fourth Edition (2004).
Our Philosophy
Our philosophy has always been that you need to be in control of your investments. Counting on a stock broker, investment adviser, accountant, general partner, or real estate investment fund leaves you completely out of control.When you are an actively engaged real estate investor, you are the one calling the shots. You are the one responsible for your successes and failures.
As we are writing this introduction, the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme has unraveled and is in the process of destroying many people’s lives. We promise you that you are the only person who can make you rich. Conversely, we promise you that you are the only person who can make you poor. Our mission is to provide you with the knowledge and information you need to be successful.And, if needed, we make ourselves available to you through our university HCIU or with fee-based consulting and partnering if you need that extra knowledge, push, information, or assistance.
Investing in Real Estate = High Net Worth
Investing in real estate is still the best vehicle to use to amass a high net worth. Do not be paralyzed into investment inaction by the negative media ranting that real estate is no longer a smart investment. Real estate has always been and always will be the small investor’s surest way to become a multimillionaire.
The Peruvian-born economist Hernando de Soto got it right when he said the West became the economic world leader when our property laws and banking system gave us the ability to turn illiquid real estate (land) into liquid money. Cash and now cash and cash flow is king of the world. This book will show you how to become king or queen of your financial world.
How to Read This Book
We recommend you read this book in a particular way. Bring a lot of energy to your reading.This does not mean that you must necessarily read the book quickly, though that is fine with us.We want you to be excited about the material. Highlighters can be your best friend. Highlight items as you go.You could even color code your highlighting.Whatever it takes to enjoy and capture the information we are sharing with you.We want you to Win Going In as you read.
If you find yourself bogging down, stop reading.The material is designed to be comprehended in bursts. See if you can go from one insight to the next.You will become energized when you do this.
We would like to hear from you about your successes. Also, we want to hear what is working and what is not working for you. Please e-mail us at thetrustee@hotmail.com or contact us through our publisher, John Wiley & Sons.
We are available to partner with you on deals that you bring to us. We are available to help you put your deals together for a fee. If we do a partnership with you, we are jointly responsible for its success. If we consult with you on one of your deals, you are responsible for your success. Remember we have thousands of investors wanting to do business with us and thousands of students wanting to receive further education from us so please be patient and our staff will get you to us as soon as possible. When you e-mail please put the target date and topic in the subject line to assist us in sorting time priorities. Remember to include all your contact information and as much detail of the project as possible to expedite our response. Good luck and good deals!
—Chantal and Bill Carey
PART ONE
CHAPTER 1
The Real Estate Market Has Crashed
Pick a city in the United States: Boston, New York, Atlanta, Miami, Dallas, Chicago, Denver, Los Vegas, Phoenix, San Diego, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Portland, or Seattle. Everywhere in the country the real estate market is crashing—just as it is in other regions around the world. Prices in all 20 major metropolitan areas in the United States measured by the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index are spiraling downward. Nationwide the index plunged 19.1 percent in the last year.
In 2008, in the United States alone, 3,000,000 homeowners received foreclosure filings on their homes.This represents 1 in 54 homes in the United States. According to a national foreclosure list company, more than 860,000 properties were repossessed by lenders last year. Many hundreds of thousands more were bought by real estate investors through short-sales or at the foreclosure auction. In the first six weeks of 2009, foreclosure proceedings began on another 296,000 homeowners according to the Center for Responsible Lending (a nonprofit organization focused on eradicating predatory lending practices).
At least 10 to 12 million households are facing foreclosure over the next four years. In the current economic downturn, 7 million to 8 million people could lose their jobs. They will not be able to make their mortgage payments. January 2009 foreclosure filings were up 18 percent from January 2008. Again, according to a national foreclosure list company 1 in every 466 households nationally received a foreclosure notice in January 2009.
Moody’s Economy.com says that 13.8 million of the 52 million United States homeowners with a mortgage (27 percent) owe more on their mortgages than their homes are worth. This is what is known as being underwater with your mortgage.
Bank repossession rose 184 percent year-over-year.According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR) in the United States, 19 percent of the inventory of existing homes for sale in January 2009 was bank real estate-owned (REO) properties.This creates a huge downward pull on real estate prices. The median price of a single-family home in the United States was $175,400 in December 2008 down 15.3 percent from a year ago.What happened to the housing boom?
Financial Derivatives Have Crashed the Real Estate Market
Financial derivatives have crashed the real estate market worldwide. A financial derivative is a contract between a buyer and a seller that derives value based on an underlying asset like a stock or a real estate mortgage. Poor quality mortgages were the underlying assets for trillions of dollars in high-cost derivatives. How did this happen?
A poor quality mortgage occurs when a borrower stops making monthly payments. Media attention has been focused on the subprime mortgage borrower. These were borrowers who were not qualified for A paper or prime mortgage loans. Banks loaned them money based on these borrowers’ ability to breathe on a mirror and fog it up.These loans could be characterized as B, C, or D paper.
However, many borrowers of A paper and Alternative A (Alt A) paper have stopped making their mortgage payments, too.Alt A mortgages were given to borrowers who may have had good credit but had no long-term ability to make monthly mortgage payments.These were a version of NINJA loans. A NINJA loan means No Income, No Job, and (No) Assets.
Adjustable Rate Mortgages
Many A paper and Alternative A (Alt A) paper borrowers’ inability to continue making monthly mortgage payments were exacerbated when the mortgage came with an adjustable interest rate and/or adjustable monthly payment. After the initial teaser rate with its correspondingly low payment changed with the first rate adjustment triggering higher monthly payments, these borrowers could not afford to make their monthly mortgage payments.
Added to this banking debacle was the normal cyclical nature of the real estate market. Just as the top of the real estate cycle was being hit and a normal price leveling or price decline was occurring, the rates and payments on millions of real estate loans were adjusting upward.
Savings and Loan Crisis
In the 1980s, the United States experienced a crisis in the savings and loan industry. Cheap credit, nonexistent lending standards, and weak government regulation caused hundreds of savings and loan institutions to fail.Today, we have those same three factors at work plus two new ones.
The first new factor is that banking is no longer local. Banking is now global. Look what happened to the country of Iceland when its banks went under.The government collapsed.The second new factor is the packaging of mortgage debt into securities (derivatives) beyond the control of any government regulation.
From 1995 to 2005, Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, and Citi-group became international players buying and selling stocks and bonds and managing assets such as mortgage-backed securities for big fees.This has been referred to as the universal bank model.
Acting Locally and Globally
These big banks were acting locally and globally. From 1995 to 2008, bank branches in the United States went from 81,000 to 99,000. This was a 22 percent increase. First-time home buyers and people wanting to pull equity out of their homes were encouraged to come in and borrow money. Unscrupulous mortgage brokers aggressively pursued predatory lending practices in order to maximize their profits.
In one of the most egregious cases of predatory lending practices discovered so far, Ray Vargas of Cerritos, California, was hit with unconscionable lending fess, prepayment penalties, and interest charges.An investigation by msnbc.com showed that in a “21-month period in 2005 and 2006, Vargas’ home was refinanced five times through a total of six loans.”
According to msnbc.com his loan total went from $213,555 to $745,000. To access this $531,445 in equity Mr. Vargas “paid at least $123,237 in loan origination fess and prepayment penalties,” according to the report. He paid another $60,000 in interest. This occurred as he was coping with the death of his wife of 57 years and her huge medical and nursing home bills. By the way, Mr.Vargas is 84. So what did the banks do with all these new loans?
Bundling
The banks then bundled together trillions of dollars of these mortgages and sold them to investors all around the world. Mortgages on properties in California, Nevada, Florida, or Rhode Island would become the underlying assets to financial derivatives sold to hedge funds in Paris, London, Singapore, or Shanghai.
In the past, credit had been extended based on the borrower’s ability to repay the loan. Now credit was being extended based on the lender’s ability to package a mortgage loan as a security instrument and sell it. Mortgage borrowers like Ray Vargas were just a means to an end. The big investment banks like Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, and Goldman Sachs saw how much money was being made and jumped into the game.
Wall Street Took over Main Street
Wall Street took over Main Street.These firms bought and sold mortgage-backed securities by borrowing astronomical amounts of money. In 2006, Goldman Sachs made a $9.4 billion profit, which was the highest in Wall Street history. Morgan Stanley made a profit of $7.1 billion.Their respective CEOs were paid bonuses of $53.4 million and $41.4 million.
Then toward the end of 2006 the housing market began to cool off. Subprime loans were the first to implode.This was the beginning of the end. During 2007 and 2008, all the players involved experienced massive losses, as many borrowers in all types of mortgage categories stopped making their mortgage payments for various reasons. Banks now have $5 trillion in nonperforming assets (potential losses) crushing their balance sheets.
AIG (American International Group)
AIG made a fortune selling insurance contracts to banks and hedge funds guaranteeing the value of the derivative contracts. By the fall of 2008, the United States Federal Reserve made the decision to rescue AIG. One hundred and fifty billion dollars later and the company that we have been told is too big to be allowed to fail is still failing. Without the government rescue the whole banking system would have collapsed under the domino effect because no bank’s assets were worth the paper they were written on.
One portfolio of AIG assets the Federal Reserve holds is valued at $20 billion of residential mortgage-backed securities. A second portfolio is valued at $27 billion and consists of collateralized debt obligations, which are financial derivatives that combine slices of debt.These investment portfolios are made up of billions of dollars of toxic paper. Sorting out the toxic paper from the nontoxic paper is just one of the problems.
Financial Derivatives Are the Solution
However, noted expert and professor of economics at Yale University, Robert Shiller believes that financial derivatives are the solution to the current financial crisis. Financial derivatives are a risk management tool according to Shiller. He equates them to an insurance policy.“You pay a premium and if an event happens, you get a payment,” says Shiller.
Robert Shiller is the Shiller of the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index. Movement in this index can be traded on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange.
Shiller wants homeowners and lenders to be able to insure themselves against falling housing prices. He proposes doing this by using a version of a financial derivative. Let’s look at an example.
Example
You buy a home for $350,000.You make a 20 percent down payment of $70,000.You borrow $280,000 from your mortgage lender.
Home Purchase
You buy a derivative that is inversely related to the nearest regional S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index to your property. If the value of your property drops and by extension the Home Price Index drops, the financial derivative would go up in value and offset your loss.
Let’s say the value of your home drops 30 percent or $105,000 because of changing market conditions. Now your home is worth $245,000.
Home Value Drops
You are effectively underwater with your mortgage of $280,000 being $35,000 greater than the value of your property.
Underwater
Your financial derivative would go up in value from 0 to $105,000.
This would recoup your $70,000 down payment and your $35,000 underwater amount.
Derivative Value
Lenders Use Derivatives Locally not Globally
Lenders could do the same thing as their borrowers. By buying a derivative, the lender would have a hedge against having to foreclose and likely winding up owning property the lender is not interested in owning. If a borrower stopped paying on a mortgage loan the derivative would cure the deficiency.
It would also protect the lender from having to do a short-sale. A short-sale would require the lender to cram down the loan amount from $280,000 to $245,000 in order for the property to sell at the current market value. This would result in at least a $35,000 loss to the lender.
Lender Loss
$20 Trillion Housing Market
By having derivatives available for borrowers and lenders, the $20 trillion housing market can become more liquid. Without derivatives there are very limited ways to unlock profit when the market falls.The stock market allows options and derivatives. This allows money to be made even when the market is falling.
This significantly increases the number of buyers and sellers in the stock market. More buyers and more sellers mean more liquidity. More liquidity means a better functioning market even in turbulent conditions.
History
In the 1920s, U.S. mortgage lending was a very simple financial transaction. If you wanted to borrow money to buy a home you went to your local bank. The bank gave you the money to buy your home and you gave the bank a promissory note and a mortgage contract.
The promissory note was the evidence of your debt to your bank. The mortgage contract was the security device that gave the bank the legal right to foreclose on your ownership title in the event you defaulted on your monthly payments.
The bank got the money to loan to you by borrowing it from all the depositors who put money in the bank. In return for putting money in the bank, the bank gave each depositor a passbook showing how much money they had on deposit.The bank also paid a small amount of interest to encourage people to take their money out of their coffee cans and mattresses and bring it to the bank.
The banks made money on the interest rate spread between what they were paying their depositors and what they were being paid by their mortgage borrowers. If a bank was paying 1 percent to its depositors and receiving 4 percent from its mortgage borrowers, the interest rate spread was 3 percent. This is what is known as the primary mortgage market.
Primary Mortgage Market
The primary mortgage market is a financial transaction between the bank and a mortgage borrower. The money went from the bank to the borrower. The promissory note and mortgage contract went from the borrower to the bank.
Primary Mortgage Market
In other words, the money went in one direction and the paper went in the other direction. This system worked well until the stock market in the United States crashed and the depression of the 1930s ensued.
Recession, Depression, Panic
Let’s be clear.Today we talk about a contraction of the economy as a recession. The word is not even capitalized so as to downplay what is really going on in the economy. A recession is defined as two consecutive quarters of negative economic growth as measured by the gross domestic product (GDP).
Recessions used to be called depressions. However, politically the word depression is too unpalatable a term. So in the modern era we have sugarcoated economic difficulty with a word that sounds like something you looked forward to in grade school: recess-ion.
The United States in the 1870s had banking panics. By the 1930s the political powers that be substituted the word depression for panic. Talking about an economic depression had a much milder emotional impact than talking about an economic panic. It also allowed politicians to get reelected.
Crisis of Confidence
The reality of the 1930s was another banking panic. People wanted the banks to give them back their cash when the economy got into trouble. All the depositors showed up at the same time and said,“Here is my passbook. Give me my money.” But the banks could not comply.
The banks had loaned out the money for people to buy real estate. The banks had very little cash because they were holding the mortgage papers. This is called a run on the bank. Thousands of banks failed. Millions of Americans lost all their money.
History Repeats Itself
History is now repeating itself.According to RBC Capital Markets, 1,000 banks will fail in 2009 and 2010. In July 2008, we had the run on IndyMac Bank.This was a national banking conglomerate with $32 billion of assets. Unfortunately, many billions of these assets were toxic.The bank was rocked by losses on defaulted mortgages made at the top of the housing boom.
In September 2008, Washington Mutual was seized by the United States government. Over a 10-day period $16.4 billion in deposits was withdrawn from the bank by panicked customers. Before it collapsed Washington Mutual was the sixth largest bank in the country. It held more than $327 billion in assets.This was 10 times the amount of assets held by IndyMac Bank. It was the largest bank failure ever. Perhaps we should say so far.
Fannie Mae
In response to the collapse of the primary mortgage market in the 1930s because of the lack of liquidity in the system, the United States federal government created the Federal National Mortgage Association or Fannie Mae in 1938.The purpose of Fannie Mae was to create a secondary mortgage market and prevent banking panics.
Secondary Mortgage Market
The mortgage paper would be passed from the bank to Fannie Mae. In return, Fannie Mae would send money to the bank. That way, when the depositors showed up with their passbooks and said, “Give me my money,” the bank actually had the cash to give them.
Secondary Mortgage Market
The bank went from being the owner of the mortgage paper to being the servicing agent for Fannie Mae and receiving a fee for collecting the mortgage payments from the borrower.
The secondary mortgage market system was expanded in 1968 and again in 1970. In 1968, Fannie Mae acquired a sister, Ginnie Mae, the Government National Mortgage Association. The Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, Freddie Mac, was added in 1970.
What most people do not know is that Fannie Mae was privatized in 1968 to remove its activities from the federal budget. Freddie Mac has been privately owned since its inception. Even though they both had the word federal in their names, neither company was federal until the federal government took them over in the last quarter of 2008. Now they are both “federalized.”
Today
Today there are $10.5 trillion in mortgages in the United States according to the Federal Reserve. More than 90 percent of these mortgages are now owned by someone other than the bank that made the loan in the primary mortgage market.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac got into trouble because they packaged and sold mortgage-backed securities. Fannie and Freddie wanted more liquidity and profits so they created a tertiary mortgage market. They sold the mortgage-backed securities to hedge funds in return for big cash profits.
Tertiary Mortgage Market
This tertiary mortgage market was a global market. It was a giant Ponzi scheme played out on the global stage in trillions of dollars. As long as everyone was making big fees packaging and servicing these securities, then everything was hunky-dory-copasetic-peachy-keen.
In fact, it was impossible to determine the value of the securities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were selling. That is still the problem today. No one can figure out how to separate the toxic securities from the nontoxic securities.
Once the housing market cooled in the United States and people stopped making payments on their mortgages, the cash flow that drove this whole system dried up. One part of the United States government bailout was the immediate cash infusion of $66 billion in combined subsidies to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
The Impasse
So far the solution to this mortgage mess has remained at an impasse. The impasse was described quite succinctly by Steve Preston, a former housing secretary in the Bush administration: