Allen & Unwin’s House of Books aims to bring Australia’s cultural and literary heritage to a broad audience by creating affordable print and ebook editions of the nation’s most significant and enduring writers and their work. The fiction, non-fiction, plays and poetry of generations of Australian writers that were published before the advent of ebooks will now be available to new readers, alongside a selection of more recently published books that had fallen out of circulation.
The House of Books is an eloquent collection of Australia’s finest literary achievements.
Georgia Blain has written a number of novels for adults including the bestselling Closed for Winter, which was made into a feature film. Her memoir Births Deaths Marriages: True Tales was shortlisted for the 2009 Kibble Literary Award for Women Writers.
In 1998 she was named one of the Sydney Morning Herald’s Best Young Novelists and has been shortlisted for the NSW Premier’s Literary Awards, the SA Premier’s Awards and the Barbara Jefferis Award. She lives in Sydney with her partner and daughter.
The Blind Eye
This edition published by Allen & Unwin House of Books in 2012
First published by Penguin Books Australia Ltd in 2001
Copyright © Georgia Blain 2001
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10 per cent of this book, whichever is the greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act.
Allen & Unwin
Sydney, Melbourne, Auckland, London
83 Alexander Street
Crows Nest NSW 2065
Australia
Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100
Email: info@allenandunwin.com
Web: www.allenandunwin.com
Cataloguing-in-Publication details are available from the National Library of Australia
www.trove.nla.gov.au
ISBN 978 1 74331 388 6 (pbk)
ISBN 978 1 74343 084 2 (ebook)
Acknowledgments
A True Constitution
The First Consultation
The Field
Spider
Pearl
Belladonna
Snake
The Direction of Cure
The Unknown World
Sources
This book was completed with the assistance of a grant from the Australia Council and a fellowship at the Varuna Writer’s Centre. It wouldn’t have been possible without the help of both these organisations.
I would like to thank Peter Tuminello, who answered all of my questions about homeopathy with considerable patience. I want to stress that this book is a work of fiction, and that the proving and process of cure I have referred to may differ in some respects from what I believe is the usual practice.
Thanks also to Jinks Dulhunty who gave me access to her library of homeopathic texts. I hung on to them for a long time and hope I haven’t returned them in too decrepit a state. I am also very grateful to Rosie Scott, who has always been the mentor that everyone hopes to find. Rosie, Anne Deveson, Andrew Taylor and Peter Bishop from the Varuna Writer’s Centre all had the unenviable task of reading earlier drafts and having to tell me the truth. I am grateful for their honesty. Thank you as well to Louise Marsh, who gave me advice on medical matters.
Finally, I also want to thank Fiona Inglis, my agent; Fiona Daniels, who edited the manuscript; and Julie Gibbs, Ali Watts, Sophie Ambrose and everyone else at Penguin who worked very hard in getting this book to its final form.
. . . we have only to rely on the morbid phenomena which the medicines produce in the healthy body as the sole possible revelation of their in-dwelling curative power, in order to learn what disease-producing power, and at the same time, what disease-curing power, each individual medicine possesses.
Samuel Hahnemann, Organon of Medicine
I, of course, have no idea what it is that we are testing.
There are twelve of us here, including myself, and none of us knows. This blindness, both on the part of the people who will be taking the potential remedy, and the four supervisors (two men, myself and Seamus; and two women, Jeanie and Samantha), is essential if we are to build up a picture of the true nature of the substance we are proving. Any knowledge on our part would only distort each of our responses. You can imagine how it would be. We would not be able to help ourselves. If we heard the word ‘venom’ whispered, we would immediately begin to suspect our own bodies of displaying the toxicological effects with which we are familiar; we would find ourselves exhibiting a certain expected nature on all levels, the low mean strike of repressed passions spitting forth a venomous poison. Even our dreams would be tainted by all that we bring to that word. Or perhaps it is a plant we know, a mineral, maybe even a diseased tissue that we are testing; in each case we would see what we think we should see, we would bring all that we associate with that substance to this process, and our time would have been wasted.
There is, of course, a director. She is not here with us, but she does know what the remedy is. I met her several times before I decided to leave my practice for a period so that I could take part in this trial. I had been wanting a break, a change in my life, and when I heard of the scale of this particular proving, and the manner in which it would be conducted, I was curious to find out more. But it was not until the director told me the location for the first phase of this experiment, that we would be staying about three hours north of Port Tremaine, that I made up my mind to take part.
She, and the others who work with her, chose this country because the air is dry and the water clean. It is also close to an ideal level above scawater, approximately 400 metres. The food we eat is organic and we are far from the stresses of a hectic urban life. Although the experiment will not be conducted solely in these conditions (it is essential that we also obtain a picture of the remedy within each subject’s normal environment), this initial testing will help ensure we get a more reliable set of results than we would otherwise have obtained.
For the first two weeks, the purpose of being here is simply to raise the health of the subjects to as, high a level as possible before the dosage is administered. We need to know the nature of each person’s true constitution. As part of this process, everyone has been keeping their diaries as instructed, meticulously noting each deviation from their normal state at least three times a day, as well as any possible causes for these changes. This will continue when the provers commence taking the potential remedy (or placebo, in the case of some) and this is when my job will become more demanding. I am meant to monitor my two subjects, to be available for discussion, and to ascertain if and when a dosage should be discontinued. But at this stage I have less to do, and I have had moments of coming close to the quiet I have been craving.
During the days, we walk, write, read and talk, some of us preferring to be with others in the group, some of us wanting to be alone. At night it is cold, a sharp chill that sends us to bed early, so that we wake when the first light reveals a brittle frost across the flatness of the high country, low tufts of grass crunching beneath our feet, each step imprinted dark against silver.
I have been taking time to be by myself, sometimes walking for hours through the prehistoric gorges that surround us, hearing only the sound of my footsteps on the rocks and the occasional cry of a bird in the brilliance of the cloudless blue sky. On other days, I sit out on the verandah that wraps around the house in which we are staying and I look out at the vastness of this land.
The truth is, I have had Silas on my mind. Far more so, since I came here. But that is hardly surprising, considering our proximity to PortTremaine and the fact that I ultimately chose to be involved for that very reason. No matter how much you try to guard against it, there are some patients whose stories do not leave you, and the reasons why this occurs may not be ones that you expect, nor may they be particularly rational or readily explicable.
When I stopped at Port Tremaine on my way out here, I wanted to know if Silas had gone back as he had indicated he would the last time I saw him. I also wanted to see it for myself, the town that he had told me about and, more so, the garden in which Rudi and Constance had lived. It had been some years since he had been there, and the differences between what he had described and what I saw could, in certain instances, have been attributed to the passing of time. There was still so much, though, that may never have measured up against the visions he had conjured up for me and the stories he had told.
As I drove away, heading towards the smear of wheat-coloured sky above the darkness of the ranges, and the beginning of my time in this place, I found myself attempting to piece together the fragments of everything I had learnt about him, both from our sessions together and from information I have since obtained elsewhere.
The last time I saw Silas, I told him that an illness returns to its source before cure.
We look to what the very first symptoms were, I explained, and we are not surprised to find them reappearing as the healing process nears completion. This is the direction that cure takes.
He had looked away.
I need to go back, he had said.
And although at that stage I had not completely understood the reason why, I had hoped he would meet my eyes, that I would see some realisation of the strength he had found in having reached the point of making such a statement, but he had kept his gaze averted from mine.
It was, in fact, four years ago that Silas first went to Port Tremaine. He was, as he once tried to explain, a different person before that journey. He was like a tight coil that suddenly whipped up from the ground; a whirlwind that took leaves with it in a flurry; a wind that only died to start up again, picking up rubbish this time, a discarded piece of paper, cigarette butts, string, and dying down once more, only to appear seconds later, with no sense or purpose to its path.
He was twenty-four and had never had a job of any consequence. There was no need. He had a trust fund, and access to other sources of wealth that had been carefully secreted away from the authorities’ eyes for many years. He came from a family that I had heard of, that most people would have heard of, and although his surname was one that was associated with bankruptcy under dubious circumstances (and with considerable shame), he did not flinch as he spelt it out for the receptionist.
Silas was living in one of his family’s apartments at the time immediately preceding his departure, a huge place that had previously belonged to his grandmother. His parents were in Rome, a city his mother always found stifling in its conservatism, particularly after their years in Barcelona. She would ring late at night, often drunk from several afternoon Camparis, to complain about the expected tedium of that evening’s dinner party and to tell him how much she missed him.
If she found him at home, he had usually only just come in, invariably with a group of friends, all of them out of it, and he would put her on speaker phone, so that they could all talk; his enthusiasm for the dinner they’d had, the bar they’d been to, the conversations (or lack of) that had made up the evening, always out of proportion to the reality of the occasion.
She would ask him how Rachel was and he would say that she was fine, everyone laughing now because it had been several months since they had split up, and she would tell him that she was pleased; put her on, Silas, darling, and someone would start talking, start pretending to be Rachel, even if they had never met her in the first place.
In those days, he was rarely alone. With more money than he could possibly know how to spend, he found that people gathered around him, aware that he could, and would, provide food, drugs and entertainment for all. Silas knew this, and it never bothered him. He wanted the company, he needed people to affirm his existence; unless, of course, he was in one of those times.
What times? I asked him during one of our earlier sessions together, when we were still laying down the basis from which we could begin to work.
When I was shutting down, when I couldn’t bear to see anyone.
When the whirlwind died.
And it had a periodicity? I asked.
He did not know what I meant, and I explained. Did it come up regularly, this depression, did it occur at the same given times?
He thought for a moment and told me he wasn’t sure. In the case of his slump just prior to his departure, it was his mother’s death that had triggered the incident.
But I guess I was heading that way anyway, he said, looking out the window.
Throughout the time he had lived in a different country from his parents, Silas had only maintained contact with his mother. When he heard she had died, he felt, he told me, as though he was without anchor, completely adrift. He stopped answering the phone, he stayed at home by himself, he drank too much, and he took more drugs than usual (dope, cocaine, whatever, he explained). A friend of his father’s had booked him a ticket to go over to Italy, and although he had intentions of going, at the last minute he changed his mind.
Not consciously, he said. I just didn’t get on the plane.
When I asked him what eventually prompted him to go to Port Tremaine and make such a radical alteration to his life, Silas told me that he supposed it was a conversation he’d had with a friend of his, Jake.
Jake was a yoga teacher who lived in the apartment building opposite. He and Silas had sex, not often, just sometimes when they ran into each other walking home at night, or heading out on a Saturday morning.
Three weeks after he received the news of his mother’s heart attack, Silas saw Jake out on the street. There had been a storm. Hailstones, like oranges, had hurtled out of the sky, pummelling cars and shattering windows, bringing everyone out in its wake. The road was covered in debris, car alarms wailed and people wandered around like spectators at a carnival, amazed by the damage. In the sparkling stillness, Silas just observed the mayhem and breathed in the sweetness of frangipani and lemon-scented gum, flowers and leaves pulverised by the ice.
Jake told him that he looked terrible, which he did.
You could do with a retreat, he suggested and he stretched out on the parquetry floor of Silas’s bedroom, legs in the splits, as he reached for his big toe. This was the kind of thing he did after sex, and Silas smiled wryly as he told me that it was one of the reasons why their relationship had never gone any further than it had.
Why don’t you get away? His body bent in the other direction. Take some time out, find out what it’s like to be without all this, and he waved his hand around the room.
It was a throw-away suggestion, but it was one that stuck.
Silas wanted to keep moving, he had to, it was the way in which he survived, and at that stage he would have clung to anything that seemed to hold any possibility of pulling him out of the state he was in.
In the days that followed, he began to toy with the idea. He had received a list of his mother’s assets from one of the family’s solicitors. It was the value of the house that he noticed first. The solicitor had scrawled a figure, $15 000, followed by a series of question marks next to the brief description, ‘four bedrooms, dilapidated’. Silas could not believe anything could be so cheap, and he searched maps for the name of the town.
It was three hours south of the country in which she had grown up, a station that is probably not far from the place where I am staying now. Silas had seen faded black and white photographs of her childhood home – bleached barren land, country that rolled for miles under flat, hard skies – and as he traced his finger around the coastline, he read names like Cape Disaster, Desperation Point and then, finally, the far more ordinary Port Tremaine.
He began to spread maps across the floor, splashing red wine across the terrain, conjuring up visions of who he would be, what he would do when he got there, convincing himself that this was a possible direction to take; but more than that, it was the answer to the stultifying emptiness that was threatening to crush him. And, if he hated it, if it was a wrong move, well, he could always just come back. There was nothing to hold him anywhere really.
As Silas told me the story, he glanced up at the clock. In those initial appointments, I could see his discomfort each time we began to discuss Port Tremaine, as well as his desire to talk, both at odds with each other.
I am not a therapist, I told him during our first session, that is something you should understand. If you feel it’s therapy you need, or if you just want to confess all your crimes and misdemeanours, I may not he the person for you.
He looked away as he shifted in his chair.
It’s just that I’m not equipped to guide you in the ways you might be expecting. I knew I needed to be gentle with him, because he was, like so many patients, uncertain as to why he had come and fearful as to what he would find himself revealing. The help I offer is remedies. Remedies that will hopefully alleviate not only the physical symptoms, but the mental and emotional as well, if that’s what you need. In order to choose the remedy, we may have to visit the past, but we will be doing so in a particular way.
Silas nodded, trying to look as though he understood, as though he had nothing to hide.
In those early days, I was never sure whether we would make any progress. I could see he did not have any faith in what I do (in fact, like most of my patients, he had close to no understanding of the process), but over the years since his return from Port Tremaine, he had found no help from traditional medicine, and he had become, as he admitted reluctantly, somewhat desperate.
As he sketched out his life for me prior to that trip, I was astounded at the hedonistic abandon that had clearly been an integral part of who he was. Not because it shocked me, but because the change that had occurred appeared to be so dramatic.
Even as a child he had never been able to keep still. The numerous nannies who were hired to look after him had usually quit after a couple of weeks. There was a brief period in which his mother had taken him to psychiatrists, all of whom had pronounced him to be precociously bright, somewhat difficult, but quite within the range of normal, and with no relief to be found in their verdicts, she had decided to just accept the way he was. If the nannies threatened to quit, she offered them a raise. When that didn’t work, there was always another who would take the job (particularly with its accompanying salary). If Silas had too much energy, well, there was no point fighting it, and she took to bringing him down from his room for dinner-party guests, his wild dancing to any music they chose to play always a sure source of entertainment, particularly after they’d had a few drinks. And as he got older, there were the boarding schools.
Eight by the time I was sixteen, he admitted.
Why? I asked.
He looked out the window as he listed his sins: selling drugs, sex in the dormitories, refusing to participate in sport; he was even an instigator in a Gay Pride rally despite having no clear sexual preference. Just the usual stuff, he told me.
His parents finally found an experimental school that was willing to take him.
The School Without Walls.
I smiled as he told me the name. I knew it. I had been there myself, three years earlier.
Similar sins, I told Silas, unable to hide the glimmer of amusement in my eyes as I remembered the way in which I, too, had rebelled, shortly after my mother was first hospitalised with depression, and how my father, an analyst, believed that the answer was more freedom, rather than less.
It was at that moment that Silas decided he would attempt to trust me, despite the misgivings he’d had on first entering the building and seeing the tenants listed at the entrance: aura readers, psychic healers and colour therapists.
As he shifted in his chair and looked around the consulting room, he told me he wanted this to work, he needed it to work, and I promised him I would do all I could to help.
Silas had been living with the way he was for three years before he saw me. Looking back, I do not know how he did it.
As I sit outside in the brightness of the morning sun remembering our conversations, I can hear the others packing a picnic lunch and I know I will soon have to join them. I have found myself becoming increasingly antisocial (not just here, but in life generally, although at home this trend is less obvious than it is in a place such as this where I have to live with others), and I do not know how to reverse this process, or if, in fact, I even have the will to attempt it.
Are you working on something? Hamish asked me this morning. He is one of the provers and he has been encouraging everyone to do yoga with him in the morning, refusing to give up on those of us who promise him we will be out there on the verandah with him in the freezing cold, just not today, not this particular dawn, but tomorrow.
He wanted to know whether I was writing a new text, and I told him I was simply using the time as space in which to think, that it was something I had been craving.
I guess it must get draining, treating people, he said.
Not really. It was an automatic response, and as I uttered it I realised there was no need to lie. I smiled at him. Actually, it does.
I had never expected the degree of exhaustion that I would experience in full-time consulting, and this is not to say that I do not enjoy my work. I am lucky, I have found what is right for me. Six months into my medical degree, I stumbled upon this field and switched courses, despite considerable advice to the contrary. Suddenly, I had discovered a whole new way of looking at the world, and at the end of my studies I was eager to begin practising. I wanted to heal, I still do; it is just that sometimes the weight of other lives, the intensity of the process that is necessary with each and every patient, can be overwhelming, and I was ill-prepared. In my eagerness to make a difference, I took on too much. Worse still, I am, for various reasons, a person who finds it difficult to mark off where responsibility for another should end. I manage, but I am only just coming to realise the price I have paid, and despite my repeated vows to remedy the situation, I have done nothing about it until now.
Silas once told me that he had often spent weeks completely alone. After his return from Port Tremaine, he did not, in fact, see anyone for over a month; he just stayed in his apartment, with all the curtains drawn. Finally he stepped outside into the warmth of the late summer sunshine and walked to the street corner, uncertain as to what to do with himself when he got there. He stood for an hour, watching the old ladies with their immaculate hair and too-bright lipstick walking their tiny dogs, the junkies arguing with each other, the council workers sweeping the previous night’s refuse into piles, the heated exchange between a waitress and a young man who had ordered his coffee over ten minutes ago; all of it spread out, distant and unreal, in front of him.
That was when he saw Rachel. As she hurried across the street, tiny, thin, her mouth brilliant red in the paleness of her face, he remembered when he had thought he was in love with her, the brief time when he would have done anything for her, and he called out her name, without thinking.
She was surprised to see him. She had heard he’d been away, some impossibly small town somewhere, and he told her the name of the place, knowing it would mean nothing to her.
For godsakes, why did you go and do that? she laughed.
I don’t know, he said, and he didn’t. He had no idea why he had done anything he had done.
She looked at him, concerned for a moment, but she was in a hurry, he could see that, and any vision he’d had of them talking now seemed foolish. Rachel, and everyone else he had known from the time they had been together, belonged to a life that had gone; they could have no place in his existence as it was now.
Give me a call, she said. You look like you need to get out.
And he tried to sound convincing as he promised her he would.
The image you have of a place when you see it on a map rarely concords with the reality that confronts you when you arrive.
I had heard Silas’s descriptions of Port Tremaine so I had an idea of what the town would be like when I first turned off the highway in the direction indicated by the sign, but he had nothing to help him build a picture of what he would find. It was a holiday place, he supposed: beaches, old shacks, a milk bar selling ice-creams, a house where he would paint, maybe write, perhaps just lie around and read; it didn’t matter. Now that he had decided this was what he wanted to do, he was determined that it would be amazing, incredible, something he should have done years ago, and that was how he would envisage it.
He drove for two days with Tess Davis in the passenger seat next to him. After three nights of toasting his departure, she had been the last one left at his apartment, and the next morning he had talked her into getting in the car with him. Come on, he had urged, throw caution to the wind, not wanting to recognise that somewhere, deep inside, he was scared; and, still drunk, she had finally just shrugged her shoulders and grinned: why the fuck not?
As the country became increasingly barren, desert brush and prickly pear stretching flat before them, the sky unrelentingly blue overhead, they talked less and less. Driving past abandoned roadside stalls, collapsed signs promising cheap flowers, vegetables, fruit, one kilometre away, five hundred metres and then, there at the promised site, nothing, they passed a joint back and forth without a word.
I think I want to go home, she eventually said when they pulled up at a service station near the entrance to the gulf, the water a dirty grey on the horizon.
With the car door open an inch, Silas could feel the blanket of dry heat hovering still around him, breathtaking in its ferocity.
It’s not far, he urged. Look at it, and he waved his arm, trying to indicate how extraordinary it was, not wanting to look at her, not wanting to see the realisation of where she was in her eyes.
There was a bus station two kilometres back along the road and he drove her there, gave her some money and told her he’d write. She just stared at him in disbelief.
Aren’t you going to wait with me? she asked.
He hadn’t wanted to. He feared that if he stopped he wouldn’t go on. He was also so stoned that he hadn’t even thought of the obvious, that it probably wasn’t okay to just leave her on the highway. They sat in the car with all the doors open, hoping to catch a breeze from the gulf but none came. Thick clusters of flies clung to their faces, their legs, their arms, barely moving when they tried to flick them away. Silas would have just given up on them, but Tess kept brushing at them, her hands occasionally slapping against his neck or his cheek in her attempts to get them out of the car. He was close to the point of hitting her back when he finally saw the bus, its metal roof shimmering in the distance.
There it is, and the sudden volume of Tess’s voice made him jump.
She was out of the car immediately, waving her arms in the air, not wanting to risk even the slightest possibility that it would go past without stopping, barely looking at him in her eagerness to get away, her fare in one sweaty hand, her bag in the other. As the doors clanged shut behind her, she did not even turn to wave.
See you, Silas called out to the departing bus.
As he watched her go, he caught a glimpse of his face in the rear-vision mirror, tired, his eyes bloodshot, the sweat trickling through the dirt on his forehead, and he was surprised that he was still where he was, there by the side of the road in the long hard heat of the afternoon.
Silas drove that last four hours with the radio off, the sun slowly sinking as he passed derelict buildings, golden in the afternoon light, some no more than walls crumbling into the sandy soil, others more recently deserted, pubs with doors barred shut, empty houses with gardens choked by thistles, boarded-up shops, their signs faded and rusty.
He pulled over at the turn-off to Port Tremaine and looked behind him at the last of the light hitting the ranges in the distance, the dark red now faded to a dusky mauve, the slopes flecked with trees, tufts of olive against the purple. It was cooler now and he could finally feel a slight breeze from the gulf as he rolled another joint and drank the last of the bottle of water Tess had left on the floor. He lit the joint and got out of the car.
This was country that had been decimated. I know, I saw it. Lured by months of surprisingly good rainfall, the settlers who first went there had thought it would be rich land, farming country where wheat would grow, golden and strong, but as years passed and the rain failed to return, they realised they had been fooled. Those who stayed were left with nothing but a memory of what might have been, in a place that proved far harsher than they would ever have believed.
As Silas walked across the paddock, the dry grasses scratching his ankles, he saw the great ravines that rip across the land, the surrounding soil collapsing in upon itself, cake-like. He touched the edge of a mound of dirt with his toe and watched it crumble, dirty yellow, revealing another inch of tree roots beneath his feet, and he traced them back with his eye to where it stood, the only tree in sight.
Fifty kilometres to Port Tremaine. That was all. He could see the faded black paint on the sign and he knew it would take him no more than twenty minutes to get there. It was not going to be the seaside village he had envisaged, there was no point in pretending otherwise, and he ground the last of the joint into the dirt and headed back to the car.
. . . case-taking is an art. The interviewer can be compared to a painter who slowly and painstakingly brings forth an image which represents in its essence a particular vision of reality.
George Vithoulkas, The Science of Homeopathy
I have to at least try to be honest with myself; I have to at least admit that my preoccupation with Silas is not just due to the fact that he was a patient I found particularly interesting, it is also because he was responsible for bringing Greta back into my life. Because the truth is, each time I remember him, I am also drawn back to her, and I flinch, uncomfortable with her renewed presence in my consciousness, unable to leave it alone, yet still not knowing how to make peace with this particular aspect of my past.