Cover Page
image

The IFT Press series reflects the mission of the Institute of Food Technologists – to advance the science of food contributing to healthier people everywhere. Developed in partnership with Wiley, IFT Press books serve as leading-edge handbooks for industrial application and reference and as essential texts for academic programs. Crafted through rigorous peer review and meticulous research, IFT Press publications represent the latest, most significant resources available to food scientists and related agriculture professionals worldwide. Founded in 1939, the Institute of Food Technologists is a nonprofit scientific society with 18,000 individual members working in food science, food technology, and related professions in industry, academia, and government. IFT serves as a conduit for multidisciplinary science thought leadership, championing the use of sound science across the food value chain through knowledge sharing, education, and advocacy.

IFT Press Advisory Group

Nicolas Bordenave

YiFang Chu

J. Peter Clark

Christopher J. Doona

Jung Hoon Han

Florence Feeherry

Chris Findlay

Thomas J. Montville

Karen Nachay

Martin Okos

David S. Reid

Sam Saguy

Fereidoon Shahidi

Cindy Stewart

Herbert Stone

Hilary Thesmar

Yael Vodovotz

Ron Wrolstad

 

Bob Swientek (IFT)

Melanie Bartelme (IFT)

David McDade (Wiley)

 

image

Membrane Processing for Dairy Ingredient Separation

 

 

Edited by

Kang Hu

Global Dairy Ingredients, Land O’Lakes Inc., Arden Hills, Minnesota, USA

James M. Dickson

Department of Chemical Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8S 4L7

 

 

 

 

 

logo.gif

Titles in the IFT Press series

 

 

 

image

Acknowledgment

This book would not have been possible without the work from all the contributors. It is their unique background and experience on membrane technology that bring the depth and color to this book. We express our appreciation to the publisher, John Wiley & Sons, particularly to David McDade, Fiona Seymour, Audrie Tan, and Lea Abot, for their patience and assistance during the past three years.

As well the book editors, Kang Hu and Jim Dickson would like to thank the continued support of McMaster University. Kang Hu acknowledges the support of Land O’Lakes. Jim Dickson wishes to thank the hard work of all the students that have worked with him over the years many of whom continue to work in membrane science and engineering.

Kang Hu and James M. Dickson

Preface

According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2011, about 730 million tonnes of milk were produced annually from around 260 million dairy cows.1 The vast majority of this production goes to feeding humans in various forms including raw milk, various processed milk products, and cheese. However, many valuable components exist within milk that are or can be produced industrially, such as lipids, proteins, minerals, and vitamins, by using various separation processes on milk and/or milk by-products. Membrane-based separation processes have proven to be effective in recovering these products and this book is concerned with such processes.

Dairy ingredients, such as lipids, proteins, peptides, lactose, and dairy minerals, provide a wide variety of potential for product development in the food, chemical, and pharmaceutical industries, due to the functional, nutritional, and biological characteristics, which are strongly influenced by the processes used for manufacturing. Among all dairy ingredient processes, separation processes are quite essential for fractionating ingredients from fluid milk. These processes could be as simple as just reducing pH to coagulate casein proteins or as complicated as isolating immunoglobulin G (IgG) by chromatography. Membrane separation processes have been applied in the dairy industry for many decades. One of the earliest applications was an ultrafiltration process to make soft cheese by Maubois, Macquot, and Vassal (1969) due to several advantages of ultrafiltration including increased yield and low energy consumption.2 Compared to traditional membrane applications, such as water treatment and desalination, ingredient separation from fluid milk has particular challenges due to the high solid content and complicated composition of fluid milk, which increases the complexity of separation processes. With the continued development on membrane materials and membrane element configurations, almost all types of membrane processes have now been successfully applied in the dairy industry for solid concentration, ingredient separation, and waste recovery.

This book provides detailed information on the development of a variety of membrane separation technologies in dairy ingredient separation as they have evolved over the past decades. The approach in this book is to view membrane separation processes for dairy ingredient separation from a chemical engineer’s point of view; that is, rather than just viewing a membrane as a tool to obtain the ingredients, the book also addresses questions of mathematical modeling, design, and optimization of the treatment systems. The text also presents in-depth knowledge of the mechanisms of each membrane separation process, as well as the membrane and module types applied in the dairy industry. Model equations are given to help the audience understand the processes and to help predict results (rejection, fractionation, and flux), and what factors are important for process control for these systems.

Microfiltration membranes, with relatively larger pore sizes (in the range of 0.1 to 10 µm) than other membrane processes, are typically used for dairy protein fractionation. In Chapter 1, the use of microfiltration processes for serum protein (or native whey protein) fractionation from skim milk is illustrated. Comparing this to traditional cheese-whey processes to obtain this protein ingredient, there are no changes in pH and ionic strength during the microfiltration process, resulting in less denaturation of the protein and more purity of the product streams, which then provides better functionalities of the ingredients.

Ultrafiltration is probably the most widely used membrane process in dairy ingredient manufacturing. Chapter 2 provides a comprehensive review of the current state of knowledge in using polymeric ultrafiltration membranes for separating dairy ingredients (with an emphasis on lactose recovery). The factors affecting lactose (also called milk sugar) separation/fractionation and the effects on yield are discussed in detail. The concept and principles of integrated membrane bioreactor to attain the functional dairy products are also presented. Finally, the future and challenges in separating milk sugar for a production of low-lactose milk and other value-added products are discussed. Chapter 3 focuses on the fouling occurring during ultrafiltration. In this chapter, the mechanism of ultrafiltration fouling and the factors affecting fouling are described, and certain fouling-control strategies are suggested. Chapter 4 proposes that placing a charge on the ultrafiltration membrane fundamentally changes separation mechanism, allowing fractionation of proteins with a similar size but different net charges. This chapter spells out the utility of charged ultrafiltration membranes for dairy protein fractionation, and also for traditional protein concentration applications where a significant flux increase is observed compared to uncharged ultrafiltration membranes.

Nanofiltration is used in the dairy industry to remove sodium chloride from solutions. This can include the de-salting of milk protein concentrates, whey, or lactose solutions. The approach can also be used to recover important minerals, notably calcium and magnesium. Chapter 5 outlines the key features of such membrane systems, including the type of membranes usually employed and the mineral species of interest during these filtration processes.

In dairy ingredient manufacturing processes a large amount of water is consumed and this water ends up in waste streams with pollutants that must be further treated. In Chapter 6, reverse osmosis membrane processes are reviewed and discussed for the application to purifying dairy waste streams to produce a more concentrated waste stream and a clean permeate water stream for reuse. Such preconcentration before evaporating and drying saves energy consumption and reduces the residence time in heat environment, resulting in lower operation costs, and reduces denaturation of the milk proteins. The permeate water from reverse osmosis is almost “pure” water that can be reused for process diafiltration and system clean-in-place (CIP) cleaning; in CIP the permeate water is used to generate cleaning solutions for membrane systems and other processing equipment. Thus considerable advantages on cost saving and environmental sustainability are realized.

Besides the above widely used membrane processes, several unique and emerging membrane separation processes have also been applied for ingredient production. Chapter 7 deals with the current status of pervaporation membranes for dairy aroma concentration. The fundamentals of the pervaporation process for aroma extraction are presented and the membranes suitable for dairy aroma enrichment are documented. The various aspects related to the aroma recovery (e.g., the nature of aroma compounds, permselectivity of the membrane, and the interactions between the aroma compounds and the membrane materials) are discussed. Chapter 8 examines protein purification and analysis methods using membrane chromatography. This chapter discusses some of the more conventional applications such as purification and polishing of proteins before moving on to newer and lesser known applications such as analysis of protein aggregates and the use of membrane stacks as bioreactors for enzymatic and synthetic modification of proteins. Chapter 9 reviews electrodialysis that has recently been applied to separate efficiently certain dairy ingredients. The principles of conventional electrodialysis as well as mass transport phenomenon through ion-exchange membranes are first described. Then hybrid electrodialysis processes using bipolar and filtration membranes are highlighted. After that, recent results on conventional and advanced electrodialysis processes for the separation, purification, and fractionation of dairy ingredients from milk, whey, or milk by-products are presented.

This book should prove to be of value to anyone working in the development and design of membrane-based systems for recovery of products in the dairy industry. Overall, the contents of this book cover the majority of membrane separation processes used for dairy ingredient separation and product stream production. It includes membrane-based separation technologies that have been recently commercialized, which is of substantial interest to the dairy industry. As well the book includes some cutting-edge technologies that have been thoroughly researched and have a great potential to be commercialized in the near future. The target audience are those professionals, such as process and system design engineers and ingredient product developers. This contemporary information and experience-based knowledge will be of great use to those professionals in membrane and membrane processing industries, leading to greater potential for the commercialization of the membranes and the processes in dairy related industries described in this book.

Kang Hu
James M. Dickson

NOTES

List of contributors

Abhiram Arunkumar, PhD
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering
1605 Linden Drive
Madison
WI 53706, USA

Laurent Bazinet, PhD
Institute of Nutrition and Functional Foods (INAF)
Dairy Research Center (STELA)
Department of Food Sciences and Nutrition,
Université Laval,
Pavillon Paul Comtois
Québec, Canada G1V 0A6

Sheng Dai, PhD
School of Chemical Engineering
The University of Adelaide
Adelaide
South Australia 5005,
Australia

James M. Dickson, PhD
Department of Chemical Engineering
McMaster University
Hamilton
Ontario, Canada L8S 4L7

Mark R. Etzel, PhD
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering
1605 Linden Drive
Madison
WI 53706, USA

Xianshe Feng, PhD
Department of Chemical Engineering
University of Waterloo
Waterloo
Ontario, Canada N2L 3G1

Raja Ghosh, PhD
Department of Chemical Engineering
McMaster University
1280 Main Street West
Hamilton
Ontario, Canada L8S 4L7

Kang Hu, PhD
Department of Chemical Engineering
McMaster University
Hamilton
Ontario, Canada L8S 4L7
and
R&D
Land O’Lakes Inc.
Arden Hills
MN 55126, USA

Bo Jin, PhD
School of Chemical Engineering
The University of Adelaide
Adelaide
South Australia 5005, Australia

Dharmesh Kanani, PhD
Principal Scientist
Process Sciences
Natrix Separations Inc.
5295 John Lucas Drive, Unit 6
Burlington
Ontario, Canada L7L 6A8

Sandra E. Kentish, PhD
Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering
The University of Melbourne
Melbourne
Victoria 3010, Australia

Suwattana Pruksasri, PhD
Department of Biotechnology
Faculty of Engineering and Industrial Technology
Silpakorn University
Nakhon Pathom 73000, Thailand

Gwynneth Rice, PhD
Beca Pty Ltd
L4, 5 Queens Rd,
Melbourne
Victoria 3004, Australia

Panida Sampranpiboon, PhD
Department of Chemical and Material Engineering
Rangsit University
Pathumthani 12000, Thailand

Masoumeh Zargar, PhD Candidate
School of Chemical Engineering
The University of Adelaide
Adelaide
South Australia 5005, Australia

Boya Zhang, PhD Candidate
Department of Chemical Engineering
University of Waterloo
Waterloo
Ontario, Canada N2L 3G1