“The wealth management industry is being redefined as we speak. While robo-advice will drastically change how financial institutions serve mass-affluent clients, goals-based wealth management is becoming the golden standard for high-net-worth firms. Paolo Sironi's book provides a holistic and comprehensive look at these complex industry changes.”
–Alois Pirker, Research Director, Aite Group
“FinTech Innovation is a FinTech survival guide for anybody who manages, invests or saves money. Disruption in Asset Management is coming fast and this book highlights how to benefit from innovation such as Robo-Advisory and Goal Based Investing. This is a must-read book by Paolo Sironi, a global FinTech Thought Leader!”
–Susanne Chishti, CEO, FINTECH Circle; Chairman, FINTECH Circle Innovate; Co-Editor, The FINTECH Book
“This is a thoughtful and superbly executed look at how financial technology has brought welcome changes to the world of investment management. This is essential reading not only for next generation investors but all investors who want to fully understand how money -their money -will be managed going forward.”
–Mark Landis, Founding Partner, Wavelength Capital Management LLC
“Paolo Sironi succinctly captures FinTech's role in the escalating disintermediation of the Wealth Management industry, while offering a logical rationale for what may lie directly ahead. The convergence of investment advice and planning via potential real-life simulations will create a new path for Global Wealth Managers. Goal Based Investing may very well offer regulatory and revenue solutions for a rapidly changing industry.”
–Mark Cipollina, Executive Director, Head of Investment Advisory UK, Standard Chartered Bank
“This book presents a bold new vision on Fintech and Goal Based Investing! Just in time for the largest wealth transfer in history. Goal Based Investing and FinTech solutions are in the minds of every millennial and baby boomer who is millennially-minded.”
–April Rudin, CEO/Founder, The Rudin Group
“It's simple. If you want to know what the future holds for wealth management, ask Paolo Sironi. His latest book presents a personal vision of financial advice that all market participants must heed to stay relevant, and ultimately to stay in business.”
–Aki Ranin, FinTech blogger and Entrepreneur
“This book presents a masterly account of the shifts in the digitalization of financial services and wealth management seen from the perspective of a bank, advisor and investor.”
–Anthony Christodoulou, Founder, Wealthtrack –Robo-Investing Europe
“Paolo Sironi takes us beyond the hype to remind us that FinTech Innovation is about customer outcomes. This book provides insights on how quantitative finance and digital technologies can be combined to change the way the wealth management industry can help consumers achieve their goals.”
–Stephen Huppert, Partner, Deloitte Consulting
“Paolo Sironi's book courageously addresses a transformation that is just starting to happen. Before the dust settles, he captures the essence of the shift from plain vanilla auto-investing to the next generation. He offers a qualitative and quantitative framework that can address the issue holistically: Goal Based Investing with Gamification elements. A strategic solution that Sironi examines from both sides of the spectrum: the financial services provider and the end-user point of view.”
–Efi Pylarinou, Founding Partner, Daily Fintech
This edition first published 2016
© 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd
Registered office
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, United Kingdom
For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
Wiley publishes in a variety of print and electronic formats and by print-on-demand. Some material included with standard print versions of this book may not be included in e-books or in print-on-demand. If this book refers to media such as a CD or DVD that is not included in the version you purchased, you may download this material at http://booksupport.wiley.com. For more information about Wiley products, visit www.wiley.com.
Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book.
Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services and neither the publisher nor the author shall be liable for damages arising herefrom. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Sironi, Paolo, author.
Title: Financial innovation: from robo-advisors to goals-based investing and gamification / Paolo Sironi.
Description: Chichester, West Sussex, UK: Wiley, 2016. | Series: The Wiley finance series | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2016011452| ISBN 9781119226987 (hardback) | ISBN 9781119227182 (epub)
Subjects: LCSH: Financial services industry—Technological innovations. | Finance—Technological innovations. | Financial engineering. | BISAC: BUSINESS & ECONOMICS / Finance.
Classification: LCC HG173 .S54 2016 | DDC 332.6—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016011452
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
ISBN 978-1-119-22698-7 (hardback) ISBN 978-1-119-22719-9 (ebk)
ISBN 978-1-119-22718-2 (ebk) ISBN 978-1-119-22720-5 (obk)
Cover design: Wiley
Cover image: Charts image: (c) Sergey Nivens/Shutterstock; Plant image: (c) Romolo Tavani/Shutterstock
To my champion and the beloved creatures of my family
So far, most of my professional life has been spent at the intersection between FINance and TECHnology, whose line of separation has recently been blurred by financial technology companies (FinTechs). The forces that are fostering their innovative mindset are unveiled in this book, which closely scrutinizes the revolution occurring in the wealth management industry, and particularly digital advice, personalized investing, and cognitive analytics being used to give insight into the behaviour of customers. The findings are based partially on market research and academic material, but mostly on what I owe to the hundreds of business conversations with industry leaders, innovators, entrepreneurs and colleagues. They have enriched this book, transformed any business travel that I have undertaken into a scholarly opportunity, and ultimately made my humble career, which started in risk management, an invaluable journey. Back in the 1990s, I learned to implement advanced quantitative methods to manage trading risks and I engaged periodically with top managers and regulators in search of graphical yet robust simulation methods to turn complex mathematical equations into intuitive reporting. When the wind of innovation blew at my door in the early days of the FinTech revolution, I was easily led on an entrepreneurial journey, it was my goal to change the investment experience as it existed between financial advisors and their respective clients, to allow them to speak more comfortably the intuitive language of Goal Based Investing (whose quantitative foundations are demonstrated in my previous book Modern Portfolio Theory: from Markowitz to Probabilistic Scenario Optimisation). I then had the privilege and deep learning opportunity to engage with the extensive network and client base of IBM on a global scale. This contributed to refining the strategic thinking at the heart of this book about the many challenges that small and large wealth management firms face in a disrupted landscape made of technology developments, generational shifts, changes in investors' behaviour, tighter regulation, and declining revenues in the traditional models of financial advice. Wealth managers do stand at the digital epicentre of a tectonic fault, which is disrupting their landscape that has, in many ways, been unchanged for centuries.
On the institutional side of this fault, FinTechs have been building new business models, such as automated investment services, that compete fiercely with established banking operations. There is an ongoing debate about the future of the industry and the chances of FinTechs to disintermediate incumbent organizations fully. Whether they will settle in as the new leaders, or will die like a bee after expending its sting, cannot really be divined and is not the primary scope of this book. We are not siding either with David or with Goliath. What we are instead concerned with is any innovation that can transform the investing experience to benefit each and every one of us, the community of taxable investors and their human or digital financial advisors. As a matter of fact, FinTechs have already won the first round of the innovation battle, as incumbents have started to update their business models and compete in a challenging race to zero prices. Robo-Advisors, for example, were born as “garage companies” using digital tools to on-board customers and enhance their experience to disintermediate retail and private banking relationships. They also developed advanced technology to operate automated portfolio rebalancing, to squeeze trading costs to a minimum, and disintermediate the role of asset managers.
On the other side of the fault, the community of end investors is also shifting in response to technology trends which are transforming social behaviour globally. Not only Millennials but older generational cohorts are embracing with unforeseen facility all aspects of the digitalization of everyday life. From a wealth management perspective, their willingness to become more digital in handling their investments has further lowered the barriers to entry.
The transforming forces at play inside this fault are unprecedented. The offer-side has always dominated the wealth management relationship because financial institutions had unrivalled placing power with private clients. They could team up with product factories, such as asset managers and desks of capital markets, to embed hefty fees into financial products, collect them from final investors, and redistribute them among institutional players. The loss of reputation suffered by these players during the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) has seeded the regulatory terrain with new legislation, which is breaking the financial services' cartel in favour of final consumers, by raising fiduciary standards and enforcing greater transparency. While the offer-side is becoming progressively a “constrained offer-side”, the community of investors is granted the flexibility to disintermediate centuries-old banking frameworks with relatively easier to understand investment experiences, any time, anywhere, at a much lower costs. This process of digitalization of the banking relationship is encouraging the demand-side (private clients) to take a more conscious and proactive role, empowering individuals and with them their personal financial advisors or digital intermediaries, and threatens to relegate wealth management institutions to lower margin business models.
The epicentre of this figurative earthquake is indeed located in the process of remodelling the asymmetry of information, which has always characterized the relationship between institutions and final clients, and kept the tectonic fault between them stable. This is now being pulled apart! The community of investors, intermediated by smart and tech-savvy financial advisors, can now become the new price-makers and force banks to be price-takers as part of a global process of banking democratization.
The book takes us on a journey below the disrupted surface of the wealth management industry, providing insights into what happens in its underlying layers. Deep within the crust, digitalization and demographic changes coupled with social media and Big Data analytics are colliding against established economic interests. Yet, this seismic activity is not just unsettling the technological and business landscape around but is also creating new minerals, a process known by scientists as flash evaporation. Goal Based Investing (GBI) is the resulting gold mine enriching the fault zone and is permitting early adopters of robo-technology to transform disruption into sustaining innovation. The theory of innovation provides a framework that helps to explain where the forces of change originate from, what is happening in the marketplace, and how the industry can evolve once robo-technology becomes mainstream.
Pre-eminently, Goal Based Investing seems to be the new normal in investment management as it provides a solution to fee-only businesses attempting to showcase their added value. Although such an investment philosophy is not new in economic studies, the industry has never truly felt compelled to realign to its best practice imperatives: traditional sales models have long proven that product-driven organizations were profitable. Moreover, technology constraints did not previously allow the building of the right customer experiences and make GBI principles effectively engaging. But this has now been solved by the usage of application programming interfaces (APIs), new digital tools, and faster than ever computing power. Furthermore, Gamification is emerging as a new digital force in the wealth management ecosystem. Goal Based Investing can provide the consistent mindset to gamify investments by simulating personal goals, market scenarios, and life events to enforce more adequate investment behaviour.
Discussing new methods (Goal Based Investing) and developing new solutions (automated rebalancing, API analytics, Gamification) might not be sufficient to enforce industry change if the economic incentives don't remodel as well within the firms themselves. In the present day widespread market regulation about fiduciary standards is facilitating a realignment to sounder client/portfolio-centric approaches. This enhancement is not cost free, and it requires a change of perspective from a traditional asset management point of view (optimization of the market variables) to a more personalized investment modality (elicitation of investors' ambitions and fears over time). In such a transforming environment, in which investors' fears and their long-term aspirations take centre stage, GBI principles will gear financial advice and financial planning to converge, and thus allow customization of the investment offering around clients' ultimate goals, generating premium services to tier and drive profitability (hence sustaining innovation). GBI robo-winners will be best placed to outpace laggards, whether FinTechs or digital incumbents.
Individual investors, financial advisors, portfolio managers, technology and digital managers, banking executives, and FinTech entrepreneurs can gain strategic insights about the transformation of the wealth management industry by reading this book and understanding the links between new technology and quantitative finance, as well as adapting to a tighter market regulation and higher fiduciary standards. Technology experts will learn about the rationales behind the many requests and challenges addressed to them by business owners. Financial professionals will learn how new technology can transform their business models and advisory workflows. To help facilitate this learning journey the book is organized into three parts:
The first and introductory chapter presents a high-level model for banking transformation and refers to the theory of innovation, which is the rationale that links disruptive technology (Robo-Advisors and automated rebalancing) and sustaining innovation (Goal Based Investing and Gamification). Today's disruption is threatening a variety of market participants and goes beyond the fate of human advisors: ETF providers, mutual funds, active funds and platforms are all primarily affected. While digitalization lowers the barriers to entry and reduces intermediation margins, Goal Based Investing allows us to personalize and differentiate the investment offer to increase revenues, and thus calibrate to the clients' requirements by means of social and behavioural analytics.
The second part opens with the second chapter of this book, which provides a non journalistic definition of Robo-Advisors and a discussion about their strengths and weaknesses. They have five main attributes: they are automated digital businesses, they promote passive investing, they provide automated portfolio rebalancing and tax optimization, they engage customers on personal goals and behaviour, and they are single minded businesses.
The third chapter examines the changes in the marketplace, with particular reference to the offer-side of the supply-demand mechanism. All actors involved in the industry are affected by these changes, which Robo-Advisors seem to exploit. The chapter looks into the future of robo-advice and explains how tech-savvy financial advisors can use indexation and robo-technology to their competitive advantage. They can use algorithms for “alpha” generation (that is model portfolios provided by automated rules) and focus on “gamma tasks” to justify their fees (that is human added-value advice and financial planning). Financial advice and financial planning begin to converge, as Goal Based Investing leads the way.
The fourth chapter focuses on mega trends affecting the behaviour of the demand-side, made up of the variety of private and taxable investors. Since Millennials and Baby Boomers are shown to interact differently with digital media, financial advisors can learn to optimize their practices by tiering the clientele on digital and goal-based groups: clients' triage is no longer a function of disposable wealth but a function of their personality and techno-literacy.
The fifth chapter summarizes the most compelling dilemma of the wealth management industry and sketches the potential outlook of a highly digital supply-demand chain. The key factor is the personalization element, hence the usage of robo-technology to facilitate a holistic Goal Based Investing approach to financial well-being.
The third part is therefore dedicated to Goal Based Investing and Gamification.
Part Three opens with the sixth chapter of the book, which describes Goal Based Investing (GBI) as the ultimate step in personalization within the journey of wealth management innovation, which sits at the crossroads between classical portfolio theory and behavioural finance. Individuals seem to make investments according to their mental state at a particular time, hence they exhibit multiple goals, multiple priorities, multiple investment horizons, and multiple risk tolerances. The probability of achieving/missing a target becomes the key analytics to generate and discuss in a GBI compliant investment policy.
The seventh chapter features a quantitative discussion about the most common approaches of portfolio modelling, which have been adopted by the first generation of Robo-Advisors. Alternative solutions are also featured, such as Probabilistic Scenario Optimization (PSO), to strengthen GBI implementation, allow for graphical representations of past and future performance, guide investors and advisors in making consistent decisions of portfolio rebalancing, and provide a framework for scenario analysis and quantitative Gamification.
The eighth chapter provides further insights about Gamification, which is more art than science, but seems to provide a chance to support a behavioural finance effort to rewire investors' brains towards a sounder investment engagement, by means of exposing them to gamified investment experiences.
Finally, the author gives his concluding remarks, certain that the readers can by then appreciate –albeit not necessarily share –all the theories, evidence, and reasoning that this book provides.
I am sincerely grateful to the numerous clients, colleagues, and friends who, knowingly or unknowingly, have enriched my whole professional life. In particular, I owe thanks to Thomas Martin who has provided continuous feedback and constructive criticism to shape some of the ideas featured in this book, and to Anil Suri who has rewarded me with open conversations during my NY travels, which also refined my vision about Goal Based Investing and Gamification. I am also grateful to my colleagues at IBM Risk Analytics, my professional family in the broader IBM, for their incessant dedication, and Wiley's editor Thomas Hyrkiel, for believing in this thought leadership project. Most importantly, I am indebted to my family, who love me and helped me dedicate time to this work.
This book contains thoughts, strategic views, and opinions which have forged the professional background of the author but are the author's only; these do not necessarily represent the practice nor the views of my current or previous employers, nor the beliefs of my present and past colleagues.
Paolo Sironi, 2016
Paolo Sironi is a recognized author of books about portfolio management and FinTech innovation. In his current role as IBM thought leader for Wealth Management and FinTech Analytics, Paolo links FINance and TECHnology globally, demonstrating sound expertise over a number of areas including Wealth Management, Asset Management, Risk Management and Financial Technology.
Prior to IBM, Paolo founded a FinTech startup (2008) to provide Goal Based Investing solutions to wealth managers. The startup became a part of IBM (2012) following the acquisition of funding partner Algorithmics, a world leader of risk management solutions.
Paolo has a decade of risk management expertise; he was previously head of market and counterparty risk modeling at Banca Intesa Sanpaolo.
Paolo's posts can be read on LinkedIn, Twitter: @thepsironi or his personal website: thepsironi.com.