Rothschild Buildings
Campbell Bunk
London in the Eighteenth Century
London in the Nineteenth Century
London in the Twentieth Century
Zeppelin Nights
IN EIGHTEENTH- AND nineteenth-century sterling
£1 = 20 shillings (20s) = 240 pence (240d).
There is no satisfactory mechanism for calculating the modern value of old money. However, for much of the eighteenth century, 15s a week (75p) was a reasonable wage for a journeyman; comparing that to the 2016 London Living Wage of £329 gives a multiplier of around 440, so £1 of debt in the eighteenth century might be approximately £440 in today’s money. From around 1790, inflation brought average wages for the period 1790–1842 closer to £1, though still below it, so £1 might be approximately £350 in today’s money.
Professor Jerry White teaches London history at Birkbeck, University of London. He is the author of an acclaimed trilogy of London (London in the Eighteenth Century, London in the Nineteenth Century and London in the Twentieth Century, which won the Wolfson History Prize) and Zeppelin Nights, a social history of London during the First World War. He was awarded the honorary degree of Doctor of Literature by the University of London in 2005 and is a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society.
For Londoners of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, debt was a part of everyday life. But when your creditors lost their patience, you might be thrown into one of the capital’s most notorious jails: the Marshalsea Debtors’ Prison.
The Marshalsea became a byword for misery; in the words of one of its inmates, it was ‘hell in epitome’. But the prison was also a microcosm of London life and it housed a colourful range of characters, including Charles Dickens’s father. The experience haunted the writer, who went on to immortalise the Marshalsea in his work, most memorably in Little Dorrit.
In Mansions of Misery, acclaimed chronicler of the capital Jerry White introduces us to the Marshalsea’s unfortunate prisoners – rich and poor; men and women; spongers, fraudsters and innocents. We get to know the trumpeter John Grano who wined and dined with the prison governor and continued to compose music whilst other prisoners were tortured and starved to death. We meet the bare-knuckle fighter known as the Bold Smuggler, who fell on hard times after being beaten by the Chelsea Snob. And then there’s Joshua Reeve Lowe, who saved Queen Victoria from assassination in Hyde Park in 1820, but whose heroism couldn’t save him from the Marshalsea.
Told through these extraordinary lives, Mansions of Misery gives us a fascinating and unforgettable cross-section of London life from the early 1700s to the 1840s.
The place of publication is London unless indicated otherwise.
Manuscripts
ADM (Admiralty Papers), Caird Library, National Maritime Museum
Blenheim Papers, British Library
C195/8, Court of Claims: Coronation Proceedings, The National Archives
Clive MSS, British Library
Correspondence and Papers, London and Middlesex, Miscellaneous. Marshalsea Prison and Court-house, The National Archives
CRES 2/932, Office of Woods, Forests and Land Revenues and Predecessors: Unfiled, The National Archives
Diocese of Winchester, Probate, Archdeaconry Court of Surrey, London Metropolitan Archives
Elphinstone Papers, British Library
Grano, John Baptist (Giovanni Battista), ‘A Journal of My Life Inside the Marshalsea’ (May 1728–September 1729), MS Rawlinson d.34, Bodleian Library
Hardwicke Papers, British Library
Home Office Papers, The National Archives
Liverpool Papers, British Library
Middlesex Justices, Sessions Papers, London Metropolitan Archives
Nichols MSS, Bodleian Library
PALA 9/8, Miscellaneous papers related to the prison of the Marshalsea and Palace Courts (1812–42), The National Archives
PRIS 11 etc., Day Books of Commitments and Discharges, Marshalsea Prison, The National Archives
PROB/11, The National Archives
Rockingham Correspondence, Sheffield City Archives
St George the Martyr, Southwark, Composite Registers of Weddings, Baptisms and Burials, P92/GEO, London Metropolitan Archives
St George the Martyr Overseers Accounts, GM 3/1/4–6, Southwark Local History Library and Archive Collections
Sloane MSS, British Library
Southwark Deeds, Southwark Local History Library and Archive Collections
State Paper Office MS, The National Archives
Surrey Quarter Sessions Papers, Surrey History Centre
WORK 6/131/2, Office of Works and Successor: Miscellanea, The National Archives
Online Primary Sources
Ancestry.com England (http://www.ancestry.co.uk)
British Museum Image Gallery Online (https://www.britishmuseum.org/research/collection)
London Lives 1690–1800 (http://www.londonlives.org/)
Old Bailey Proceedings Online, London’s Central Criminal Court, 1674–1913 (http://www.oldbaileyonline.org/)
Newspapers etc.
Argus
Bell’s Life in London and Sporting Chronicle
Brice’s Weekly Journal
British Journal
Builder
Bury and Norwich Post; or Suffolk, Essex, Cambridge, Ely and Norfolk Telegraph
Charter
Cobbett’s Weekly Political Register
Common Sense or the Englishman’s Journal
Country Journal, or The Craftsman
Covent-Garden Journal
Daily Advertiser
Daily Courant
Daily Journal
Daily News
Daily Post
Evening Post
Examiner
Flying Post or The Weekly Medley
Fog’s Weekly Journal
Gazetteer and New Daily Advertiser
General Advertiser
General Advertiser and Morning Intelligencer
General Evening Post
Gentleman’s Magazine
Globe
Graphic
Grub Street Journal
Illustrated London News
John Bull
Lancaster Gazette and General Advertiser for Lancashire, Westmorland &c
Lloyd’s Evening Post
Lloyd’s Evening Post and British Chronicle
Lloyd’s Weekly Newspaper
London and Country Journal
London Chronicle
London Evening Post
London Gazette
London Journal
London Morning Penny Post
Manchester Times
Middlesex Journal or Chronicle of Liberty
Morning Chronicle
Morning Post
Morning Post and Daily Advertiser
Morning Post and Fashionable World
Morning Post and Gazetteer
Observer
Old England or the National Gazette
Old England’s Journal
Old Whig or the Consistent Protestant
Oracle
Oracle and Daily Advertiser
Oracle and Public Advertiser
Pall Mall Gazette
Parker’s General Advertiser and Morning Intelligencer
Penny Satirist
Public Advertiser
Public Ledger
Read’s Weekly Journal or British Gazetteer
St James’s Chronicle or the British Evening Post
St James’s Evening Post
The Satirist; or the Censor of the Times
Standard
Sun
The Times
True Briton
Universal Spectator and Weekly Journal
Weekly Journal or British Gazetteer
Weekly Journal or Saturday’s Post
Weekly Packet
Whitehall Evening Post or London Intelligencer
World
World and Fashionable Advertiser
Parliamentary Papers
Account of the Names, Trades, and Descriptions of the several persons, who have applied to be discharged under the acts of Parliament of the 53rd and 54th years of His Present Majesty’s reign . . ., 1814–15
Further Report[s] of the Commissioners appointed in Pursuance of Two Several Acts of Parliament . . . to inquire concerning Charities in England for the Education of The Poor . . .,1821–1831
House of Commons Journals
House of Lords Debates, 1st Series
Report from the Commissioners appointed to inquire into the state, conduct and management of the Prison and Gaol of . . . the Court of the Marshalsea of His Majesty’s honourable Household; and of the Prisoners in the said respective Prisons confined, 1818
Report from the Committee Appointed to Enquire into the Practice and Effects of Imprisonment for Debt, 1792
Report from the Committee Appointed to Enquire into the State of the Goals of this Kingdom: Relating to the Fleet Prison, 1729
Report from the Committee Appointed to Enquire into the State of the Goals of this Kingdom: Relating to the Marshalsea Prison; And farther Relating to the Fleet Prison, 1729
Report from the Committee on the King’s Bench, Fleet, and Marshalsea Prisons; &c., 1815
Report from the Select Committee on Acts Respecting Insolvent Debtors, 1819
Report from the Select Committee on the Recovery of Small Debts in England and Wales, 1823
Report of the Commissioners appointed in Pursuance of an Act of Parliament . . . to continue the inquiries concerning Charities in England and Wales . . ., 1840
Return of all Coroners’ Inquests held within the King’s Bench Prison and other Prisons in and near the Metropolis . . . from the 1st May 1832 to . . . 1834 . . ., 1834
Primary Printed Sources
Akerby, George, The Life of Mr James Spiller, the Late Famous Comedian. In which is Interspers’d much of the Poetical History of His Own Times, 1729
Annual Register for the Year . . .
Anon., A Collection of the Yearly Bills of Mortality, from 1657 to 1758 inclusive . . ., 1759
Anon., A Companion for Debtors and Prisoners, and Advice to Creditors in Ten Letters: From a Gentleman in Prison, to a Member of Parliament . . ., 1699
Anon., A Narrative of the Late Disturbances in the Marshalsea-Prison . . ., 1768
Anon., A True description of the Mint, 1710
Anon., A True Narrative of the Great and Terrible Fire in Southwark, on Fryday the 26th of May, 1676, 1676
Anon., Hell in Epitome: or, A Description of the M—SH—SEA. A Poem, 1718
Anon. [An Amateur], Real Life in London. . . ., 2 Vols., 1821–2
Anon., The Arbitrary Punishments and Cruel Tortures Inflicted on Prisoners for Debt Represented and Described . . ., 1729
Anon., The Cries of the Poor Prisoners, Humbly offer’d to the Serious Consideration of the King and Parliament, 1716
Anon., The History of Miss Charlotte Seymour, 2 vols., 1764
Anon., The Miseries of Goals, and the Cruelty of Goalers. Being a Narrative of Several Persons now under Confinement, 1729
Anon., The Piercing Cryes of the Poor and Miserable Prisoners for Debt, in all Parts of England . . ., 1714
Anon., The Triumph of Benevolence; or, the History of Francis Wills, 2 vols., 1772
Besant, Sir Walter, London in the Nineteenth Century, 1909
Besant, Sir Walter, South London, 1898
Bickerstaffe, Isaac, The Hypocrite, 1769
Brayley, Edward Wedlake, and others, London and Middlesex; or, an Historical, Commercial, and Descriptive Survey of the Metropolis of Great Britain . . ., 4 vols., 1810–16
Brown, Thomas, The Mourning Poet: or the Unknown Comforts of Imprisonment, Calculated for the Meridian of the Three Populous Universities of the Queen’s Bench, the Marshalsea, and Fleet . . . Written by a Poor Brother in Durance, 1703
Budgell, Eustace, A Letter to Cleomenes King of Sparta . . ., 1731
Budgell, Eustace, A Letter to the Craftsman from Eustace Budgell, Esq; occasion’d by his late Presenting an Humble Complaint to His Majesty against the Right Honourable Sir Robert Walpole, 1730
Burney, Charles, A General History of Music, from the Earliest Ages to the Present Period, 4 vols., 1776–89
Chancellor, E. Beresford, Lost London: Being a Description of Landmarks Which Have Disappeared Pictured by J. Crowther circa 1879–87 . . ., 1926
Charke, Charlotte, A Narrative of the Life of Mrs Charlotte Charke, 1755 (edited and with an introduction by Robert Rehder, 1999)
Cozens-Hardy, Basil (ed.), The Diary of Sylas Neville 1767–1788, 1950
Curnock, Nehemiah (ed.), The Journal of the Rev. John Wesley, AM, 8 vols., 1909
Defoe, Daniel, A Tour Through the Whole Island of Great Britain, 2 vols., 1724–6
Defoe, Daniel The Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Famous Moll Flanders . . ., 1722 (Folio Society edn, 1965)
Dexter, Walter, The London of Dickens, 1923
Dickens, Charles, Bleak House, 1852–3
Dickens, Charles, Little Dorrit, 1855–7
Dickens, Charles, The Adventures of Martin Chuzzlewit, 1843–4
Dickens, Charles, The Haunted Man and the Ghost’s Bargain. A Fancy for Christmas Time, 1848
Dickens, Charles, The Old Curiosity Shop, 1840–41
Dickens, Charles, The Personal History of David Copperfield, 1849–50
Dickens, Charles, The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club, 1836–7
Dickens, Charles, ‘When We Stopped Growing’, Household Words, Vol. VI, No. 145, 1 January 1853
Dickens, Charles the Younger, ‘Disappearing Dickensland’, North American Review, Vol. 156, No. 439, June 1893
Dodsley, Robert (publisher), London and Its Environs Described . . ., 6 vols., 1761
Elias, A. C. Jr (ed.), Memoirs of Laetitia Pilkington, 2 vols., Athens, Georgia, 1997
Entick, John, A New and Accurate History and Survey of London, Westminster, Southwark, and Places Adjacent . . ., 4 vols., 1766
Farmer, John S., and Henley, W. E., Slang and its Analogues, Past and Present, 7 vols., 1890–1904
Fielding, Henry, Amelia, 1751
Fitzgerald, Percy, The Pickwickian Dictionary and Cyclopedia, 1900
Forster, John, The Life of Charles Dickens, 3 vols., 1872–4
Gifford, John, Complete English Lawyer; or Every Man his own Lawyer, 2nd edn, n.d., c. 1817
Ginger, John (ed.), Handel’s Trumpeter: The Diary of John Grano, New York, 1998
Goad Fire Insurance Maps, 1887–9
Goldsmith, Oliver, The Vicar of Wakefield, 1766
Hardy, W. J. (ed.), Middlesex County Records: Calendar of Sessions Books 1689–1709, 1905
Hargrave, Francis (ed.), A Complete Collection of State-Trials, and Proceedings for High-Treason, and other Crimes and Misdemeanours, 11 vols., 4th edn, 1778
Hawkins, John, A General History of the Science and Practice of Music, 5 vols., 1776
Hickey, William, Memoirs, 4 vols., 1913–25
Hill, Sir Richard, A Detection of Gross Falsehood, and a Display of Black Ingratitude; being an Answer to a Pamphlet lately Published by some Evil-Minded Person, under the name of the Revd William Woolley, striking himself A.M . . ., 1794
Historical Manuscripts Commission, Diary of Viscount Percival, Afterwards First Earl of Egmont, 3 vols., 1920–23
Historical Register. Containing an Impartial Relation of all Transactions, Foreign and Domestick . . . For the Year . . .
House, Madeline, and Storey, Graham (eds.), The Letters of Charles Dickens Vol. 1 1820–1839, Oxford, 1965
House, Madeline, and Storey, Graham (eds.), The Letters of Charles Dickens Vol. 2 1840–1841, Oxford, 1969
Howard, John, The State of the Prisons in England and Wales, with Preliminary Observations, and an Account of Some Foreign Prisons, Warrington, 1777
Howard, John, The State of the Prisons in England and Wales, with Preliminary Observations, and an Account of Some Foreign Prisons and Hospitals, Warrington, 1784
Hunt, Henry, Memoirs of Henry Hunt, Esq., Written by Himself, In His Majesty’s Jail at Ilchester, in the County of Somerset, 3 vols., 1820–22
King, Richard (A Gentleman of Fortune, Revised, corrected and improved by), The Complete Modern London Spy . . ., 1781
Knapp, Lewis M. (ed.), The Letters of Tobias Smollett, Oxford, 1970
Lennox, Charlotte, The Life of Harriet Stuart, Written by Herself, 1750 (1995 edn)
Manning, Owen, and Bray, William, The History and Antiquities of the County of Surrey, 3 vols., 1804–14
Mills, John, D’Horsay, or Follies of the Day, 1844
Miltoun, Francis, Dickens’ London, 1904
Morice, Burton, An Essay towards an History of the Ancient Jurisdiction of the Marshalsea of the King’s House. To which is subjoined an account of the Court of the Palace of the King at Westminster, created by Letters Patent of King Charles II, 1812
Neale, Robert Dorset, The Prisoner’s Guide, or Every Debtor his own Lawyer, 1800
Neild, James, Account of Persons Confined for Debt, in the Various Prisons of England and Wales . . ., 1800
Neild, James, An Account of the Rise, Progress, and Present State, of the Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts throughout England and Wales, 1802
Neild, James, An Account of the Rise, Progress, and Present State, of the Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts throughout England and Wales, 1808
Neild, James, State of the Prisons in England, Scotland, and Wales . . ., 1812
Nichols, John, Literary Anecdotes of the Eighteenth Century . . ., 9 vols., 1812–16
Noorthouck, John, A New History of London, including Westminster and Southwark, 1773
Parker, George, A View of Society and Manners in High and Low Life, 2 vols., 1781
Paterson, James, History of the Counties of Ayr and Wigton, Vol. III, Cunninghame, Part II, Edinburgh, 1866
Poole, John Ewer (‘An Eye-Witness’), An Expose of the Practice of the Palace, or Marshalsea Court; with a Description of the Prison, the Secrets of the Prison-House, its Regulations, Fees, &c. &c. . . ., 1833
Prattent, Thomas, and Denton, M., The Virtuoso’s Companion and Coin Collector’s Guide, etc., 8 vols., 1795–7
Richardson, Samuel, Clarissa; or, The History of a Young Lady, 5 vols., 1747–8 (1883 edn)
Sartain, John, The Reminiscences of a Very Old Man 1808–1897, New York, 1900
Settle, Elkanah, The Siege of Troy: A Dramatick Performance, Presented in Mrs. MYNNS’s Great Booth, in the Queens-Arms Yard near the Marshalsea Gate in Southwark, during the Time of the Fair, 1715
Shaw, Captain Donald (One of the Old Brigade), London in the Sixties (With a Few Digressions), 3rd edn, 1909
Slater, Michael (ed.), Dickens’ Journalism: Sketches by Boz and Other Early Papers 1833–39, 1994
Smith, Alexander, The Comical and Tragical History of the Lives and Adventures of the Most Noted Bayliffs in and about London and Westminster . . ., 1723
Smith, M., Memoirs of the Mint and Queen’s-Bench or, A true Account of the Government, Politics, Customs, Humours, and other Surprizing Curiosities of those Inchanted Provinces Never publish’d before. With a Character of the Marshall. In Several Letters to a Person of Quality, 1713
Smith, William, State of the Gaols in London and Westminster, and Borough of Southwark. To which is added an Account of the Present State of the Convicts sentenced to Hard Labour on Board the Justitia upon the River Thames, 1776
Smollett, Tobias, The Adventures of Ferdinand Count Fathom, 1753
Smollett, Tobias, The Adventures of Roderick Random, 2 vols., 1748
[Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts], An Account of the Rise, Progress, and Present State of the Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts, 1783
Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts, An Account of the Rise, Progress, and Present State, of the Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts throughout England, 1794
Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts, An Account of the Rise, Progress, and Present State, of the Society for the Discharge and Relief of Persons Imprisoned for Small Debts throughout England, 1799
Stapleton, Alan, London Alleys, Byways and Courts, 1924
Storey, Graham and Tillotson, Kathleen (eds.), The Letters of Charles Dickens Vol. VIII 1856–1858, Oxford, 1995
Storey, Graham, Tillotson, Kathleen, and Burgis, Nina (eds.), The Letters of Charles Dickens Vol. 6 1850–1852, Oxford, 1988
Stow, John, A Survey of London, 1603 (2 vols., edited by Charles Lethbridge Kingsford, Oxford, 1908)
Strype, John, A Survey of the Cities of London and Westminster, 2 vols., 1720
Thackeray, William Makepeace, Vanity Fair. A Novel Without a Hero, 1847–8
Thale, Mary (ed.), The Autobiography of Francis Place (1771–1854), Cambridge, 1972
Thale, Mary (ed.), Selections from the Papers of the London Corresponding Society 1792–1799, Cambridge, 1983
The Representations of the Several Fetters, Irons, and Ingines of Torture that were taken from the Marshalsea Prison . . ., 1729
The Tryal of William Acton, Deputy-Keeper and Lessee of the Marshalsea Prison in Southwark, at Kingston Assizes; on Saturday the 2d of August 1729. Upon three several Indictments, for the several Murders of Capt. John Bromfield, Robert Newton, and Capt. James Thompson, Three Prisoners in the said Prison, 1729
The Tryal of William Acton, Deputy-Keeper and Turnkey of the Marshalsea Prison in Southwark, at Kingston Assizes; on Friday the 1st of August 1729. Upon an Indictment for the Murder of Thomas Bliss, a Prisoner in the said Prison, 1729
Trollope, Anthony, London Tradesmen, 1927
Trumble, Alfred, In Jail with Charles Dickens, 1896
Trusler, John, The London Adviser and Guide: containing every instruction and information useful and necessary to Persons living in London, and coming to reside there. . . ., 1786
Tunstall, William, Ballads and some other Occasional Poems: By W—T— in the Marshalsea, 1716
Tunstall, William, St Cyprian’s Discourse to Donatus. Done into English Metre, By W—T— in the Marshalsea, 1716
Tweedie, Alexander, and Gaselee, Charles, A Practical Treatise on Cholera, as it has appeared in Various Parts of the Metropolis, 1832
Ward, Laurence, The London County Council Bomb Damage Maps 1939–1945, 2015
Wheatley, Henry B., Round about Piccadilly and Pall Mall; or, a ramble from The Haymarket to Hyde Park, 1870
Woolley, William, A Cure for Canting; or, The Grand Impostors of St. Stephen’s and of Surrey Chapels Unmasked . . ., 1794
Woolley, William, The Benefit of Starving; or the Advantages of Hunger, Cold, and Nakedness; intended as a Cordial for the Poor, and an Apology for the Rich. Addressed to the Rev. Rowland Hill, M.A., 1792
Woolley, William, Prison Meditations, composed while in confinement in the King’s Bench Prison in the Year 1795, 1796
Woolley, William, The Trials of the Rev. William Woolley, Clerk, For Publishing a Libel on Sir Richard Hill, Baronet . . ., 1794
Secondary Sources
Allen, Michael, Charles Dickens and the Blacking Factory, St Leonards, Hants, 2011
Allen, Michael, Charles Dickens’ Childhood, Basingstoke, 1988
Allen, Michael, ‘New Evidence on Dickens’s Grandparents’, Dickensian, Vol. 109, No. 489, Spring 2013
Ashton, John, The Fleet. Its River, Prison, and Marriages, popular edn, 1889
Ashton, John, The History of Gambling in England, 1898
Beattie, J. M., Crime and the Courts in England, 1660–1800, Oxford, 1986
Blanning, Tim, The Pursuit of Glory: Europe 1648–1815, 2007
Brewer, John, and Styles, John (eds.), An Ungovernable People: The English and Their Law in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, 1980
Brinley Johnson, R., ‘Little Dorrit, An Unpopular Classic’, Dickensian, Vol. XXVIII, No. 224, Autumn 1932
Brown, Roger Lee, A History of the Fleet Prison, London: The Anatomy of the Fleet, Lampeter, 1996
Brown, Roger Lee, The Fleet Marriages: A History of Clandestine Marriages with Particular Reference to the Marriages Performed in and around the Fleet Prison, London, Welshpool, 2007
Burke’s Peerage, Baronetage, & Knightage, 69th edn, 1907
Carlin, Martha, Medieval Southwark, 1996
Carlton, William J., ‘John Dickens, Journalist’, Dickensian, Vol. 53, No. 321, January 1957
Carlton, William J., ‘“The Deed” in David Copperfield’, Dickensian, Vol. 48, No. 303, June 1952
Chesterton, G. K., Appreciations and Criticisms of the Works of Charles Dickens, 1911
Church, Leslie F., Oglethorpe: A Study of Philanthropy in England and Georgia, 1932
Clarke, Norma, Queen of the Wits: A Life of Laetitia Pilkington, 2008
Connell, Philip, and Leask, Nigel, Romanticism and Popular Culture in Britain and Ireland, Cambridge, 2009
Coulter, E. Merton, ‘Was Georgia Settled by Debtors?’, Georgia Historical Quarterly, Savannah, Vol. 53, No. 4, December 1969
Duffy, Ian P. H., Bankruptcy and Insolvency in London during the Industrial Revolution, New York, 1985
Dunlop, C. R. B., ‘Debtors and Creditors in Dickens’ Fiction’, Dickens Studies Annual, Vol. 19, New York, 1990
Easson, Angus, ‘Dickens and the Marshalsea’, University of Oxford PhD, 1967 (Bodleian MS, D. Phil, d, 4231)
Easson, Angus, ‘“I, Elizabeth Dickens”’, Dickensian, Vol. 67, No. 363, January 1971
Easson, Angus, ‘John Dickens and the Navy Pay Office’, Dickensian, Vol. 70, No. 372, January 1974
Finn, Margot C., The Character of Credit: Personal Debt in English Culture, 1740–1914, Cambridge, 2003
Greene, Douglas G., ‘The Court of the Marshalsea in Late Tudor and Stuart England’, American Journal of Legal History, Vol. 20, No. 4, October 1976
Hill, Mick, Famous Pugilists of the English Prize Ring, Peterborough, 2013
Hindley, Charles, A History of the Cries of London, Ancient and Modern, 1881
Hodgson, Antonia, The Devil in the Marshalsea: Murder Stalks the Debtors’ Prison, 2014
Johnson, David J., Southwark and the City, 1969
Leavis, F. R. and Q. D., Dickens the Novelist, 1970
Lester, V. Markham, Victorian Insolvency: Bankruptcy, Imprisonment for Debt, and Company Winding-up in Nineteenth-Century England, Oxford, 1995
McCalman, Iain, Radical Underworld: Prophets, Revolutionaries and Pornographers in London, 1795–1840, Oxford, 1988 (paperback edn, 2002)
McKillop, Alan Dugald, ‘Thomson and the Jail Committee’, Studies in Philology, Vol. 47, No. 1, January 1950
Marshalsea Press, Where Dickens Dreamed of Little Dorrit, 1926
Matthews, Betty, ‘William Parke and the Royal Society of Musicians’, Musical Times, Vol. 129, No. 1746, August 1988
Melville, Lewis, The Life and Letters of Tobias Smollett (1721–1771), 1926
Mott, Graham, ‘Was There a Stain upon Little Dorrit?’, Dickensian, Vol. 76, No. 390, Spring 1980
Muldrew, Craig, The Economy of Obligation: The Culture of Credit and Social Relations in Early Modern England, Basingstoke, 1998
Ordish, T. Fairman, Early London Theatres, 1894
Owen, David, English Philanthropy 1660–1960, Cambridge, Mass., 1960
Parker, Alice, ‘Tobias Smollett and the Law’, Studies in Philology, Vol. 39, No. 3, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, July 1942
Peakman, Julie, Lascivious Bodies: A Sexual History of the Eighteenth Century, 2004
Pearce, Charles E., ‘Polly Peachum’: Being the Story of Lavinia Fenton (Duchess of Bolton) and ‘The Beggar’s Opera’, 1913
Peebles, Gustav, ‘Washing Away the Sins of Debt: The Nineteenth-Century Eradication of the Debtors’ Prison’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 55, No. 3, Cambridge, 2013
Philpotts, Trey, The Companion to Little Dorrit, Mountfield, 2003
Philpotts, Trey, ‘The Real Marshalsea’, Dickensian, Vol. 87, No. 425, Autumn 1991
Prothero, I. J., Artisans and Politics in Early Nineteenth-Century London: John Gast and His Times, 1979 (paperback edn, 1981)
Rendle, William, Old Southwark and Its People, 1878
Rendle, William, and Norman, Philip, The Inns of Old Southwark and their Associations, 1888
Rizzo, Betty, ‘Christopher Smart: A Letter and Lines from a Prisoner of the King’s Bench’, Review of English Studies, New Series, Vol. 35, No. 140, November 1984
Rosenfeld, Sybil, The Theatre of the London Fairs in the Eighteenth Century, Cambridge, 1960
Rotkin, Charlotte, ‘The Athenaeum Reviews Little Dorrit’, Victorian Periodicals Review, Baltimore, Vol. 23, No. 1, Spring 1990
Rubenhold, Hallie, The Covent Garden Ladies: Pimp General Jack & the Extraordinary Story of Harris’s List, 2005
Sadie, Stanley (ed.), The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, 29 vols., 2nd edn, 2001
Schlicke, Paul (ed.), The Oxford Companion to Charles Dickens, Oxford, 2011
Sedgwick, Romney, The House of Commons 1715–1754, 2 vols., 1970
Slater, Michael, Charles Dickens, 2009
Staples, Leslie C., ‘The Dickens Ancestry, Some New Discoveries’, Dickensian, Vol. LXV, No. 290, Spring 1949
Stirk, Nigel, ‘Arresting Ambiguity: The Shifting Geographies of a London Debtors’ Sanctuary in the Eighteenth Century’, Social History, Vol. 25, No. 3, October 2000
Survey of London, Vol. XXV: St George’s Fields (The Parishes of St George the Martyr, Southwark and St Mary Newington), 1955
Thornley, Isobel D., ‘Sanctuary in Medieval London’, Journal of the British Archaeological Association, New Series, Vol. 38, 1932
Tick, Stanley, ‘Autobiographical Impulses in The Haunted Man (1848)’, Dickens Quarterly, Vol. 18, No. 2, Baltimore, June 2001
Victoria County History, The Victoria History of the County of Surrey. Vol. IV, 1912
Whistler, Theresa, Imagination of the Heart: The Life of Walter de la Mare, 1993
White, Jerry, London in the Eighteenth Century: A Great and Monstrous Thing, 2012
White, Jerry, London in the Nineteenth Century: ‘A Human Awful Wonder of God’, 2007
Wingent, R. M., Historical Notes on the Borough and the Borough Hospitals, 1913
Wroth, Warwick, The London Pleasure Gardens of the Eighteenth Century, 1896
Young, George F., ‘The Marshalsea Re-visited’, Dickensian, Vol. XXVIII, No. 223, Summer 1932
I enter in this little book the names of the streets I can’t go down while the shops are open. This dinner today closes Long Acre. I bought a pair of boots in Great Queen Street last week, and made that no thoroughfare too. There’s only one avenue to the Strand left open now, and I shall have to stop that up to-night with a pair of gloves. The roads are closing so fast in every direction, that in about a month’s time, unless my aunt sends me a remittance, I shall have to go three or four miles out of town to get over the way.1
So Dick Swiveller, one of Charles Dickens’s more amiable debtors, made shift to exist on an empty pocket in his single room dwelling, somewhere ‘in the neighbourhood of Drury Lane’ around 1840. As a debtor he was in good company. Everyone was a debtor in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century London, as had been the case for long before. Almost everyone remains a debtor two centuries on too, though with one big difference. In Dick Swiveller’s day and before there was no generally applicable credit mechanism available from a bank or building society or credit provider that enabled a debtor to spend freely in many places to an agreed limit. Debt then was personal, between a purchaser needing credit for one or a few items and a seller prepared to provide it. It was a face-to-face arrangement between individuals who would know each other again. So debt, because personal, had spatial consequences, curtailing movement to avoid embarrassing local encounters, as for Dick. It could also involve restrictions of a more drastic kind, as we shall see.
If everyone was a debtor for a time it was not necessarily through inability or unwillingness to pay, for deferred payment on credit was the way business was generally organised. Great merchants or bankers traded not in ready money but by means of bills of exchange, a promise to pay at some point in the future, allowing time for goods to be sold or other debts gathered in. If disaster struck and merchants proved unable to honour outstanding bills they could take advantage of the bankruptcy laws and sell up in gentlemanly sessions with the Commissioners in Bankruptcy, without any of the humiliations of arrest or imprisonment that less wealthy people suffered.
For ordinary folk too, debts were an unavoidable part of everyday life. During much of the eighteenth century, specie – ready coin of the realm – was in such short supply, especially in small denominations, that it suited buyer and seller to allow an account to accumulate till it could be paid in silver or gold or, more rarely, by a banknote or draft. Paying with ready money was reserved generally for transactions between strangers – travellers at an inn, say, or buyers from a street seller or pedlar. An account or tally would be run up with the grocer, baker, butcher or milkman, all on the credit of an address given, confirmed by the tradesman’s delivery. Something ought to and might be occasionally paid on account, but otherwise the bill was rendered after a time thought reasonable by both sides: on the four quarter days, for instance, or even, for smart tailors or upholders (furnishers and interior designers) serving the quality, once a year at Christmas, when interest would be openly added to the bill. Indeed, delays in presenting a bill were considered polite. Delivering a bill or account too early was thought greedy or impertinent and could lose a customer for life. Tradesmen built into their pricing an element for bad debts, because it was anticipated that not all money owed could be gathered in.2
The poor needed credit too, perhaps none more so, when the absence of ready money might mean a family going hungry. For them special mechanisms had been constructed, like pawnbrokers who would lend money on possessions at high interest, or informal pawning arrangements at public houses or with their grocers. By the beginning of the eighteenth century a new facility had come into fashion: tallymen or ‘Manchester’ or ‘Scotch’ drapers selling ‘Cloaths and such Things’ on credit, but requiring weekly repayments from poor customers at high interest. All these transactions could go wrong and tallymen were seen as ‘a sort of Usurers’, according to a pamphlet of 1716, ‘where some of these Oppressors are said to have above a Hundred of these poor Wretches in the several Jayls in and near London at a time’.3
Although the tallymen may have been notoriously quick off the mark, the truth is that when people got into debt they usually owed money everywhere. When John Rummells, ‘Marriner’ of Greenwich, totted up his creditors while in the Marshalsea in 1725 he listed six different ‘victuallers’, probably publicans, a City tallyman and a ‘Salesman’, a butcher, baker, candle seller (tallow chandler), ‘Fisherman’ and ‘Fisherwoman’, a carpenter, an ‘officer’ (probably a Marshalsea bailiff), two ‘Marriners’, ‘Elizabeth Baker, alias Read’ (no occupation given) and three doctors (a ‘Surgion’ and two ‘Barbers’), twenty-one in all and scattered around the four naval towns of Greenwich, Deptford – or Debtford, as he once appropriately rendered it – Gosport and Portsmouth. It was the butcher who got his claim in first and made the arrest that put Rummells in the Marshalsea for £30.4
Many tradesmen devised mechanisms to avoid the losses consequent on untrustworthy credit and an unpaid bill. Landlords, those unofficial and unwilling bankers to the poor, frequently demanded prior references and a week’s or month’s rent in advance. Many shopkeepers had their own rules for refusing credit: ‘Upon my word, Sir, you must excuse me. It is a thing we never do to a stranger,’ a sword-maker in the Strand told James Boswell, who had asked to take away a silver-hilted weapon on a promise to pay later, though he relented under his customer’s haughty gaze.5 Others sought security by requiring a debtor to obtain a counter-signature or ‘acceptance’ to an IOU or promissory note, ideally a known householder or one from a good address; anyone signing, often family members or close friends, could find themselves liable for the whole sum if the debtor defaulted, and this gave creditors a further opportunity to get their money back.
Tradesmen who gave long credit were also, of course, debtors themselves. Tailors would owe drapers, cabinetmakers would owe gilders or timber merchants, shopkeepers would notoriously owe suppliers, employers would owe their journeymen wages, journeymen would owe publicans, publicans would owe brewers and so on and so forth. And any or all might owe the moneylenders if no other resource was open to them, none more experienced in the fine arts of recovering a debt through adroit manipulation of the law.
True it was, then, that all sorts and conditions of men and women were in debt. When the Morning Post analysed the occupations of 941 debtors going through the insolvency court in August 1801, it listed 252 distinct walks of life, from labourers (nineteen) to Doctors of Divinity (one). Retailers of one kind or another were prominent among them, with thirty-one ‘shopkeepers’, many others specifically described, and seventy-five ‘victuallers’, victims of countless real-life Dick Swivellers. In general, contemporary authorities agreed that debtors ending up in gaol were ‘About Two-thirds Manufacturers and Labourers – the remainder Seamen, Dealers and Chapmen [or pedlars] and various Professions’. Those who had most difficulties were additionally burdened beyond the daily vicissitudes of industrial life, tending to be ‘married; and many of them have very large Families; some Five, others Six, and others Ten Children’. Added to these, with children or without, was a small but significant proportion of women debtors, including many widows and women abandoned by men.6
When a creditor’s patience was exhausted the law provided the means to bully or frighten a debtor into paying up at last. The weapons at a creditor’s disposal meant that, for countless numbers of debtors, debt could become a galling blight on their lives, never shaken off. Many of those cultured and sophisticated men and women who made the eighteenth century a particular age of genius did so with the shadow of the debtors’ prison wall dark upon them. Artists like Gawen Hamilton, George Morland and Thomas Bonner, writers like Daniel Defoe, Sir Richard Steele, Henry Fielding, Laetitia Pilkington, Samuel Johnson, Oliver Goldsmith and John Cleland, actresses like Mary Robinson and Charlotte Charke, all saw the inside of a bailiff’s lock-up or spunging (or sponging) house, if not worse. In England, it was said in 1716, there ‘are more unhappy People to be found, suffering under extream Misery, by the severity of their Creditors, than in any other Nation in Europe’.7
Not all of them were innocent victims. Debtors might have subterfuge, dishonesty, even fraud among the weapons with which they waged war on the innocent creditor. Hiding might be the first instinct, as it was for Dick Swiveller, perhaps ‘in an obscure lodging, somewhere in the neighbourhood of Kilburn, in order to avoid the traps’, or bailiffs, it was said in 1821. Because arrests couldn’t be made at night or on Sundays, such a discreet debtor was called ‘a once-a-week man, or, in other words, a Sunday promenader . . .’8 Obscure and ancient jurisdictions gave certain places in London immunity from arrest for debt, the longest-lived of these being the ‘verge of the court’, land belonging to the royal household around the King’s Mews north of Charing Cross and extending to the royal parks. Sought-after lodgings could be rented in the verge: ‘I knew an artful fellow once’, recalled the Reverend John Trusler in 1786, ‘that eluded all his creditors, by residing there; if he wanted to go out of it, he took water at Whitehall-stairs, which place is privileged, and as no writ can be served on the water, without a water-bailiff’s warrant, which cannot be immediately procured, he would land safely in the city, or on the Surry side’, where some Middlesex or City writs had no force.9
Experienced debtors would know their way around such rabbit warrens: that proceedings in the Marshalsea or Palace court could not be brought if a debt was incurred in the City or more than twelve miles from Whitehall, nor arrests made in the City on a Marshalsea warrant alone, for instance, despite that court offering creditors the cheapest and quickest grip on those owing debts above the smallest. Even prison could be an effective hiding place, some debtors intriguing with family or friends – a man could be arrested at his wife’s suit – to work up sham actions and so stop other creditors battening on them:
The idea, that imprisonment can be a punishment to a man under these circumstances, must instantly vanish: he prepares for his catastrophe with the vizard of distress, and by that craft sets every danger at defiance; his property is conveyed by previous assignments, apparent gifts, spurious loans, and with the semblance of poverty, he possesses a genial fortune, fabricated on the ruin of the credulous, honest, and unsuspecting dealer . . . To the collusive Debtor therefore Imprisonment can be no punishment, – for he feels it not as such.10
Others still might procure two householders to bail them out of custody and then abscond abroad, leaving the creditor to recover debt and costs from the bails, a difficult and expensive process, especially if there was collusion between them all. And many debtors managed to squirrel resources away from their creditors and leave them to legatees, as the few surviving Marshalsea wills tell us: for example, Mary Young, who died in April 1750, probably in prison, left money for gold mourning rings and funeral expenses, amid other bequests; and Joseph Railton left ‘all my ffreehold Copyhold and Leasehold Estate or estates’ to John Darkin of Goodman’s Yard, Minories, in 1776.11
In the general sum of things, though, the whip hand lay with creditors. Most no doubt were honest in their intentions to recover money properly owed, aggravated beyond the limits of patience by what looked like their debtors’ refusal to pay, even after repeated and exhausting efforts to cajole or harass or shame them into doing so. Many will have been driven on by their own creditors snapping at their heels. Once they reached the end of their tether, however, the law put a terrible weapon in their hands.
A creditor’s suit was begun by swearing an affidavit quantifying the sum said to be owed. This was put before a judge by the creditor’s attorney and, with only the creditor’s word for it and without hearing from the debtor, permission would be granted to begin due process: the affidavit could be rejected only if it was defective in form, though not all defects were spotted until it was too late. If the debt sworn to was over 40s (£2; increasing to over £10 from 1779), then an arrest could be made at that point, still without the existence of the debt being proved in court, under what was known as ‘mesne process’ – pronounced ‘mean’ and denoting ‘middle’. There were many advantages to the creditor in doing so and this was the way most imprisonments were brought about. At this stage the costs of the action nominally had all to be reimbursed by the debtor. He could escape imprisonment by securing bail from two householders who in effect pledged themselves to pay any proven debt should the debtor default. If bail was not forthcoming (as in most cases), or if it was offered but not accepted by the creditor or his agent because of the inadequate standing of the debtor’s bail, then the debtor could be imprisoned – still without the debt being proved.12
There were two ways in which a debt came to trial (the ‘final’ process). A creditor could move straight to this point by way of a writ of execution and without passing through mesne process. He had to do this where debts were below the minimum of £2 (later £10); but even if debts were above these sums, at trial the original debt and costs could be loaded with damages consequent upon the debtor’s original failure to pay – debt, costs and damages had, though, all to be proved at the trial. Once proved, should debtors still remain unable to pay, they were imprisoned. The disadvantage to the creditor, however, was that from this point debtors could claim maintenance while in prison, the creditor having to pay 4d (a groat) a day (2s 4d a week) to the debtor; this obligation was introduced in 1759 by ‘the Lords Act’ and groats were increased from 1797 to 6d a day (3s 6d a week).13
Arrest and imprisonment under mesne process, attractively swift and draconian as it appeared, also involved creditors in more costs should they wish to keep a debtor in prison. Creditors had to serve a declaration on the imprisoned debtor, stating the amount of debt and costs and requiring a plea so that the matter could come to trial; this involved further attorney’s fees, which creditors would have to pay, at first at least. Declarations had to contain the names of two sureties to ensure creditors’ attendance in court to prove a case; but the law provided fictional sureties for him, named ‘John Doe and Richard Roe’, ‘Those charming creations of the poet’, as Dickens put it. But ‘the Plaintiff generally proceeds in the slowest manner’ and in any event could wait till the end of the next law term before making a declaration. There were four of these a year, some with long vacations between them, so that a debtor arrested before Christmas, say – a popular time to do so – could wait over six months before a declaration became due.14 If no declaration was served, then the debtor was ‘superseded’ and could be discharged; this was also the case where groats and sixpences were not paid punctually each week. But a discharge could take place only once papers had been lodged and prison fees paid.15
Did imprisonment or the threat of it work for the creditor? ‘[T]ho’ it be a common saying amongst us, That a Prison pays no Debts’, in many cases it did. In 1791, of 12,000 bailable writs issued against debtors only some 1,200 led to imprisonment, the rest paying up in some form, absconding, or proving such hopeless cases that creditors despaired of getting their money and let the matter drop. Arrest was also more straightforward than executing against the debtor’s goods, complex and rule-bound as that was. In any event, the goods might not have amounted to anything, while imprisonment could serve to rally friends and family to help discharge the debt. So arrest and imprisonment were widely resorted to.16
They were, though, not always fairly resorted to. Most creditors were genuine enough and dunned for their bills, repeatedly requesting then demanding they be paid – like the milkmaid with her tally or score in William Hogarth’s The Distressed Poet of around 1740. But some failed even to take these steps. ‘A man may be arrested from mere malice or caprice, without being applied to for the debt, and without any account being rendered to him of the claim: this has frequently happened . . .’ And some used trickery to inflate a debt, perhaps by getting ‘an illiterate person’ such as Francis Brasberry, a Marshalsea prisoner of 1735, to sign a note he could not read admitting to a debt far in excess of the value of the quack medicines he had received. They had been necessary to cure ‘a Rash or Scurvy humour upon him, and his wife had the Ague or ffeaver’, and were sold to him by Francis Butler, ‘who professed a Doctor’ but who ‘called up and down the Country with Baggs upon his Shoulders to Sell Medicines’.17
There were cases of a debtor spending ‘many months in prison where the court subsequently decided he owed nothing’, the House of Lords was told in 1814. And in the dog-eat-dog world of eighteenth-century London it was always possible to find someone prepared to swear away another’s liberty on a lie. Sarah Dodd or Todd, an oyster seller, was suborned by a ‘Mr. Mitchel’ to swear a debt against one Dancer which landed him for some time in the Marshalsea; she knew nothing of the man, had never in fact seen him, but was paid three guineas for her pains.18
The power of imprisonment was a godsend to the vindictive: it got a debtor quickly out of the way and it might well lead to financial ruin. So we read around 1830 of a greengrocer ruined by a competitor who loaned him stock worth 35s and then made a demand for 55s. The greengrocer offered 35s but this was refused and a Marshalsea writ issued which he could not afford to defend. The debt was ‘proved’ and he was imprisoned. His landlord, hearing of his plight, distrained against his goods for the rent and ‘sold even the bed from under his wife!’ And a false or contrived debt could be used for other reasons, perhaps to remove a rival in love. The vociferous Ann Cantwell, wife of Walter, was in the Marshalsea in 1696–7 with her child, ‘in a most miserable Condition Lying on the bare boards’. Sarah Wright, Walter’s lover’s mother, had ‘surreptitiously obtained an execution for 5:2:10’ against her. When Ann sought relief from the Middlesex Justices, who issued a warrant against Sarah to appear and answer the complaint, Sarah was said to have ‘told ye Constable she car’d not a ffart for all yor Warrants calling them butt Petty Justice . . .’19
Similarly, debt was a powerful way of raising the stakes in a family dispute. George Hovey, with his wife and child, languished in the Marshalsea for at least two and a half years from 1702 to 1705 at the suit of his allegedly prosperous mother and his brother-in-law for an affront that has not come down to us. And in 1718 ‘One Oades, a Quaker, and an eminent Potter, in Gravel-lane in Southwark’, was imprisoned by his four sons on an action for the enormous sum of £10,000 arising out of a business difference; they also evicted their mother from the home and barricaded themselves inside with their friends. They were wise to do so, because ‘a very great Tumult gather’d about the House, so that it was in a manner Besieg’d, throwing Stones, Dirt, &c. and exclaiming against them . . .’ When someone inside opened fire with a musket, killing a woman in the crowd, the Riot Act had to be read and the house was not cleared until a ‘File or two of Musqueteers’ arrived across the river from Whitehall. Oades’s youngest son and his friend were duly convicted of murder – though through influence all escaped punishment.20
Family disputes aside, some creditors tightened the screw by seizing debtors at their most vulnerable. In June 1733 it was reported that a boy of four had been arrested and confined in the Marshalsea at the suit of a Quaker surgeon – hypocrisy among the saints a popular target of the eighteenth-century press. The creditor had treated the child’s sore finger but it had mortified so he had cut it off. He then sued the child and his guardians for his bill of £15, arresting the boy rather than others involved in the suit. And in 1750 an execution against the heavily pregnant Ann Cox brought her into the Marshalsea, where she was delivered ‘of two Boys and a Girl’.21