Cover Page

ADMISSION MATTERS

What Students and Parents Need to Know About Getting into College

FOURTH EDITION



Sally P. Springer

Jon Reider

Joyce Vining Morgan




Wiley Logo

PRAISE FOR Admission Matters What Students and Parents Need to Know About Getting into College

Fourth Edition:

“If you are looking for a book where you can get the best possible advice from authors who have the ability to anticipate and answer your questions with a marvelous combination of experience and insight, then this is the book you need to buy . . . quickly!”

Gary L. Ross, vice president and dean of admission, Colgate University

“Written by deeply experienced and respected professionals, Admission Matters aims to ‘empower students and their families to make good choices . . . and retain their balance and sanity at the same time.’ Bullseye!”

Philip Ballinger, associate vice provost for enrollment and undergraduate admissions, University of Washington

“You can't ask for a better introduction into college admissions. From exploring colleges, to applying, and deciding, Admission Matters continues to be an essential, comprehensive book for high school students and families.”

Art D. Rodriguez, dean of admission and financial aid, Vassar College

“Admission Matters demystifies college admissions like no other book has, with the most current information on testing, paying for college, and finding the right college.”

Robert Massa, senior vice president for enrollment and institutional planning, Drew University, and former vice president, Dickinson College and dean of enrollment, Johns Hopkins University

“I absolutely love this book and highly recommend it as a must‐read resource for students and parents going through the college admission search and application process. It's easy to understand, current, and contains spot on advice.”

Bob Bardwell, school counselor and director of school counseling, Monson High School (MA)

“A thoughtful, thorough tour of the college selection process. Admission Matters goes well beyond the basics, and invites the student to personalize the college process as few books do.”

Patrick O'Connor, associate dean, college counseling, Cranbrook Kingswood Upper School (MI)

“Clear, comprehensive, and sane advice from trusted experts. This updated guide provides a road map to what is often a bewildering and anxious process for students and families.”

Debra Shaver, dean of admission, Smith College

“Comprehensive, insightful, based on current research and insider expertise. A straightforward guide to today's complex college admission process that is anything but straightforward.”

Bruce Reed, co‐founder, Compass Education Group

“I wish I had this book when my daughters were applying to college. Admission Matters somehow finds clarity amidst the complicated set of confusing, even contradictory college admission practices.”

Kirk Brennan, director of undergraduate admission, University of Southern California

“An enormously useful and easy‐to‐read guide to getting into college. While others may claim to be the ‘gold standard,’ this one is the real deal.”

Nancy Griesemer, independent educational consultant and long‐time blogger on colleges and the admissions process

“All readers of Admission Matters—whether students, parents, or counselors—will benefit from the deep insights and expertise of the authors. Accessible and a good read, the book provides much needed guidance for the college admissions process.”

Sam Carpenter, senior assistant director of admissions, Duke University

“This book is a ‘must read’ for all families going through the college admissions process. If you are looking for a guide to help you approach the college search in a meaningful way, this is the book for you.”

Angel Perez, vice president for enrollment and student success, Trinity College

“Admission Matters provides a straightforward, no nonsense blueprint to navigate the complex college admissions process.”

Jon Westover, senior associate director of undergraduate admissions, University of Massachusetts, Amherst

“As an experienced counselor and the parent of a high school junior, I found this book packed with so many helpful and informative ideas to share with both my students and my own children. A must‐have for every college‐bound student's household.”

Kathi Moody, school counselor, Lynnfield High School (MA)

“This brand new edition of Admission Matters is just what the doctor ordered. It is filled with wise, up‐to‐date information and insider knowledge. Families will love it.”

Marjorie Hansen Shaevitz, author and founder, adMISSIONPOSSIBLE

“This is a must‐have resource for students and families navigating the college admissions process. The authors are respected, long‐time professionals and get it right from the search to enrollment.”

Jeff Rickey, vice president and dean, admissions and financial aid, St. Lawrence University

“Admission Matters is current, insightful, non‐dogmatic and the most inclusive book about the complex U.S. college admission process I have read. I can even see using it as a training manual for my new staff on the complexity of U.S. college admission; it is that thorough and in‐depth.”

Paul Thiboutot, vice president and dean of admissions and financial aid, Carleton College

“Admission Matters is the quintessential book for anyone who wants to thoroughly understand today's college landscape. It is a must read.”

Nanette Tarbouni, director of college counseling, John Burroughs School (MO)

“This is a valuable resource, with encyclopedic information on nearly every aspect of college admission. Whether you are new to college searches or a seasoned professional, you will find answers to detailed questions as well as a rich overview of this ever‐changing and complex process.”

Ralph Figueroa, dean of college guidance, Albuquerque Academy (NM)

“Filled with both common sense and sage advice, the fourth edition of Admission Matters is the only guide any high school student—and his or her parent—will ever need.”

Jennifer Delahunty, former dean of admissions and financial aid, Kenyon College

“This updated edition is a great addition to the library of any family with college‐bound students or any counselor's library.”

William S. Dingledine Jr., certified educational planner, past president Southern Association for College Admission Counseling

“Admission Matters is the single best comprehensive guide available to help students and their families avoid the harmful aspects of the ‘admission marketplace.’ The new edition continues that noble tradition by providing essential information and tools to make the college admission process sane, humane, and perhaps even, for its fortunate readers, a great voyage of personal growth and discovery.”

Michael Beseda, vice provost for strategic enrollment management, University of San Francisco

To our children

Acknowledgments

Many colleagues have shared our goal of improving the college admissions process for students and parents and have helped us, in ways large and small, in the writing of the fourth edition of Admission Matters. We are grateful to all of them: Jed Applerouth, Terry Axe, Carolyn Barr, Bonnie Burks Becker, Jeffrey Corton, Jeffrey Durso‐Finley, Frances Fee, Duffy Grant, Vicki Kleinman, Douglas Long, Marybeth Kravets, Nancy Hargrave Meislahn, Bruce Poch, John H. Provost Jr., John Raftrey, Bruce Reed, Zita Riedlová, Gary Ross, Pam Schachter, Beatrice Schultz, Catherine Sinclair, Leanne Stillman, Ken Suratt, Marilyn van Loben Sels, Sue Wilbur, and Kim Zwitserloot.

We are indebted as well to the Jossey‐Bass editorial team for the fourth edition—Kate Bradford, senior editor; Connor O'Brien, project editor; and Sharmila Boominathan, production editor—for guiding us so capably through the publication process.

Three people who have made lasting contributions to Admission Matters through all four editions deserve special acknowledgment and recognition. The insights and wisdom of Marian Franck, coauthor of the first edition, remain an integral part of the book. Lesley Iura, then education editor at Jossey‐Bass, saw the value and potential of Admission Matters when it first arrived on her desk more than 13 years ago. Later, as publisher at Jossey‐Bass, she continued to support Admission Matters as a valued part of the Jossey‐Bass list. Professor emeritus Håkon Hope has contributed encouragement, insights, and support from the earliest stages of planning for the first edition through the final stages of reviewing page proofs for the fourth edition. His dedication to his students and their academic and personal development has been an inspiration throughout.

Finally, we want to thank the thousands of high school and college students whose lives we have touched over the course of our careers, both in the classroom and as counselors. Their dreams and aspirations have encouraged us to try to ease the path for others yet to undertake the college admissions journey.

Introduction

It is easy to understand why the college admissions process has become such a challenge, and even an ordeal, for many students and their families. Everywhere they look, families are barraged by evidence of “college mania.” Online and print media regularly regale readers with horror stories about the competition involved in gaining admission to selective colleges as application numbers rise and admissions rates fall, sometimes dramatically in a given year. Classmates, neighbors, coworkers, and even virtual strangers are all too eager to share tales about terrific kids with great academic and extracurricular records who were denied admission by the colleges of their choice.

As likelihood of admission becomes harder to predict at many schools, students find themselves applying to an increasing number of colleges to protect themselves. Of course, one major consequence of such behavior is an overall increase in application numbers and corresponding declines in admissions rates at those schools, feeding the very problem students are hoping to address by submitting more applications.

Adding to the challenge is the continuing rise in the cost of college, with the sticker price at some private four‐year colleges now approaching $70,000 per year. Recent changes in the standardized testing policies of many schools, as well as changes in the tests themselves, have also contributed to the uncertainty surrounding college admission.

The result of all of this is that families often find themselves caught up in a high‐stakes competition in which they are uncertain about the rules and even more uncertain about the outcome. Parents feel uncomfortable trying to support their children in a process that they do not completely understand and are not sure they can afford. Even those who consider themselves knowledgeable may quickly find that much of what they know is out‐of‐date or based on unverifiable hearsay.

Frank Bruni, author of a widely acclaimed book entitled Where You Go Is Not Who You'll Be: An Antidote to the College Admissions Mania, dedicated his book as follows: “To all the high school kids in this country who are dreading the crossroads of college admissions and to all the young adults who felt ravaged by it. We owe you and the whole country a better, more constructive way.”1 We fully agree.

College admissions does not have to be, and should not be, an ordeal. A clear understanding of the process can empower students and their families to make good choices for themselves and allow them to retain their balance and sanity at the same time. That has always been the goal of Admission Matters, from its first edition in 2005 through this fourth edition today.

We have written this book to demystify the college admissions process by explaining how it works and to level the playing field for those without access to extensive assistance from knowledgeable high school counselors or sometimes any counselors at all. It will also help those who have access to good counseling but would still like some extra support. Our advice is designed for students planning to apply to any four‐year college, whether highly selective or not.

Admission Matters explains

  • How rankings motivated by profits contribute to the application frenzy
  • How the admissions process really works, and what you can, and cannot, control
  • The ways in which colleges differ that really matter
  • How you can build a list of colleges that are a good fit for you and submit strong, competitive applications to gain admission to them
  • How and why many colleges use standardized tests and how you can best prepare for them
  • What recent changes in standardized tests as well as testing policies at many schools mean for you
  • When an early application makes sense, when it can be a mistake, and how to tell the difference
  • How financial aid works, what you can expect from it, and how you can increase your chances of receiving more
  • How to prepare strong applications that can help you distinguish yourself from other applicants
  • What you—student and parent—can do to work together in appropriate and respectful ways throughout the admissions process to achieve a happy outcome

And much more. In this thoroughly revised fourth edition of Admission Matters, we have worked hard to address the many changes that have occurred in the world of college admissions since our last edition. We want you, our student and parent readers, to begin the college admissions journey confidently with the latest and most complete information available. As before, students with disabilities, international students, and transfer students will find much needed guidance to address their special circumstances, as will athletes, artists, and homeschoolers. Information for first‐generation college students and undocumented students is included as well. We want Admission Matters to continue to be the most up‐to‐date, clear, insightful, supportive, and practical book on college admissions anywhere.

We recognize, however, that you may want more information on certain topics than space allows us to include. To help you access that additional information easily, we have provided a list of resources, many of them on the web, that give detailed information on topics such as financial aid and athletic recruiting to supplement our own coverage. To keep Admission Matters as up‐to‐date as possible, we are maintaining a website with free updates and additional materials. You can find it at www.admissionmatters.com. We welcome your feedback.

We feel we are especially well qualified to be your guides. Among the three of us, we have more than 100 years of experience in secondary and higher education in the roles of high school teacher and college counselor, college admissions officer, college professor and administrator, and independent educational consultant. Collectively we have worked with thousands of students across the United States and abroad. We are also proud parents of successful college graduates, so we have experienced the admissions process firsthand from the parent perspective as well. We are delighted that our readers in the general public have found Admission Matters enjoyable and easy to read, and we are honored that professional colleagues use it widely as a text in courses on college admissions for those studying to be counselors themselves.

We hope Admission Matters will serve as your trusted road map through the college admissions journey.

PART 1
What You Need to Know Before You Begin

  • Chapter 1 Why Has College Admissions Become So Competitive?
  • Chapter 2 What Do Colleges Look for in an Applicant?
  • Chapter 3 How Do Colleges Make Their Decisions?
  • Chapter 4 How Colleges (and Students) Differ: Finding What Fits