Table of Contents
Cover
Title
Copyright
FOREWORD
FOREWORD TO THE FIRST EDITION
PREFACE
CONTRIBUTORS
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
SECTION A: Theory: Human Health Assessment
1 Primer on Human and Environmental Risk Assessment
1.1 INTRODUCTION
1.2 HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT: A BRIEF HISTORY
1.3 HELPFUL RESOURCES FOR CONDUCTING RISK ASSESSMENTS
1.4 PRINCIPLES FOR RISK ANALYSIS
1.5 SUMMARY
2 Hazard Identification
2.1 INTRODUCTION
2.2 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION FOR CARCINOGENS
2.3 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION FOR NONCARCINOGENS
2.4 EVALUATING CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
2.5 AQUATIC TOXICOLOGY
2.6 SEDIMENT TESTS
2.7 BIOCONCENTRATION STUDIES
2.8 AVIAN TOXICITY TESTS
2.9 EVALUATING RISKS TO DOMESTIC ANIMALS
2.10 EARTHWORMS AND OTHER WILDLIFE
2.11 CLOSING
3 Dose–Response Modeling for Cancer Risk Assessment
3.1 INTRODUCTION
3.2 MEASURES OF DISEASE FREQUENCY
3.3 EMPIRICAL STATISTICAL METHODS
3.4 BIOLOGICALLY BASED DOSE–RESPONSE MODELING
3.5 CONCLUDING REMARKS
4 Exposure Assessment
4.1 INTRODUCTION
4.2 BASIC CONCEPTS
4.3 CONCEPTUAL APPROACHES TO EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
4.4 INFORMATION UPON WHICH EXPOSURE ASSESSMENTS ARE BASED
4.5 ESTIMATING UPTAKE VIA THE SKIN
4.6 ESTIMATING INTAKE VIA INGESTION
4.7 ESTIMATING UPTAKE VIA INHALATION
4.8 ROLE OF UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS
4.9 ISSUES IN EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
4.10 CLOSING THOUGHTS
5 Risk Characterization
5.1 INTRODUCTION
5.2 GUIDANCE DOCUMENTS ON RISK CHARACTERIZATION
5.3 KEY COMPONENTS OF RISK CHARACTERIZATION
5.4 TOXICITY CRITERIA FOR EVALUATING HEALTH RISKS
5.5 DESCRIPTORS USED TO CHARACTERIZE HEALTH RISKS
5.6 METHODS FOR QUANTIFYING HUMAN HEALTH RISKS
5.7 KEY UNCERTAINTIES IN RISK CHARACTERIZATIONS
5.8 RISK DECISION-MAKING PROCESS
5.9 INTERNATIONAL APPROACHES TO RISK CHARACTERIZATION
5.10 FUTURE DIRECTIONS OF RISK CHARACTERIZATION
SECTION B: Theory: Ecological Risk Assessment
6 Ecological Risk Assessment: History and Fundamentals
6.1 INTRODUCTION
6.2 PLANNING THE RISK ASSESSMENT
6.3 PROBLEM FORMULATION
6.4 ANALYSIS PHASE
6.5 RISK CHARACTERIZATION
6.6 RELATING ECOLOGICAL INFORMATION TO RISK MANAGEMENT DECISIONS (COMMUNICATING RISK)
SECTION C: Case Studies Involving Contaminated Water
7 Hexavalent Chromium in Groundwater: The Importance of Chemistry and Pharmacokinetics in Quantitating Dose and Risk
7.1 BACKGROUND
7.2 MECHANISTIC ASPECTS OF INHALATION AND ORAL TOXICITY OF CR(VI)
7.3 REGULATORY CRITERIA FOR CR(VI) RISK ASSESSMENT AND RISK MANAGEMENT
7.4 KEY SCIENTIFIC ISSUES AND CONCERNS
7.5 EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT RESEARCH
7.6 RESEARCH ON SYSTEMIC CR(VI) DOSE AND TOXICITY
7.7 CONDUCTING A RISK ASSESSMENT AND DOSE COMPARISON
8 Estimating the Value of Research: Illustrative Calculation for Ingested Inorganic Arsenic
8.1 INTRODUCTION
8.2 EXAMPLES USING INGESTED INORGANIC ARSENIC
8.3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
8.4 CONCLUSIONS
SECTION D: Case Study Involving Contaminated Soils
9 Risk Assessment of Chromium-Contaminated Soils: Twelve Years of Research to Characterize the Health Hazards
9.1 INTRODUCTION
9.2 SITE DESCRIPTION AND HISTORY
9.3 STRATEGIC DIRECTION OF THE SPECIAL REMEDIAL ORGANIZATION
9.4 DATA COLLECTION EFFORTS
9.5 EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
9.6 TOXICITY ASSESSMENT FOR TRIVALENT AND HEXAVALENT CHROMIUM IN COPR
9.7 RISK CHARACTERIZATION
9.8 PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS OF THIS ANALYSIS
9.9 CONCLUSIONS
SECTION E: Characterizing Exposure to Air Contaminants
10 Quantification of Variability and Uncertainty: Case Study of Power Plant Hazardous Air Pollutant Emissions
10.1 INTRODUCTION
10.2 COMPILATION OF DATABASE FOR THE CASE STUDY
10.3 DEVELOPMENT OF PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTION MODELS
10.4 QUANTIFICATION OF UNCERTAINTY IN THE FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION FOR MODEL INPUTS
10.5 ESTIMATING VARIABILITY AND UNCERTAINTY IN A MODEL OUTPUT
10.6 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
10.7 CONCLUSIONS
11 Characteristic Time, Characteristic Travel Distance, and Population-Based Potential Dose in a Multimedia Environment: A Case Study
11.1 INTRODUCTION
11.2 METHODS
11.3 CASE STUDY
11.4 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
SECTION F: Evaluating Occupational Hazards
12 Methods for Setting Occupational Exposure Limits
12.1 INTRODUCTION
12.2 HISTORY OF OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS
12.3 RISK ASSESSMENT CONSIDERATIONS
12.4 FACTORS TO CONSIDER WHEN SETTING OELS
12.5 METHODS FOR SETTING OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS
12.6 BIOMARKERS-BASED OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS
12.7 FACTORS TO CONSIDER WHEN SETTING BEIS
12.8 METHODS FOR SETTING BEIS
12.9 CONCLUSION
13 Worker Hazard Posed by Reentry into Pesticide-Treated Foliage: Reassessment of Reentry Levels/Intervals Using Foliar Residue Transfer–Percutaneous Absorption PBPK/PD Models, with Emphasis on Isofenphos and Parathion
13.1 INTRODUCTION
13.2 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
13.3 RECENT ISSUES
13.4 HAZARD EVALUATION
13.5 EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
13.6 PROCEDURES FOR CALCULATING A REENTRY INTERVAL
13.7 REASSESSMENT OF REENTRY INTERVALS, FOLIAR RESIDUE TRANSFER/PERCUTANEOUS ABSORPTION PBPK/PD MODELS
13.8 DISCUSSION
SECTION G: Case Study Involving Exposure to Radionuclides
14 Dose Reconstructions for Radionuclides and Chemicals: Case Study Involving Federal Facilities at Oak Ridge, Tennessee
14.1 INTRODUCTION
14.2 BACKGROUND
14.3 IODINE-131 RELEASES FROM X-10 RADIOACTIVE LANTHANUM PROCESSING
14.4 MERCURY RELEASES FROM Y-12 LITHIUM ENRICHMENT
14.5 POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS (PCBS) IN ENVIRONMENT NEAR OAK RIDGE
14.6 RADIONUCLIDES RELEASED FROM X-10 TO CLINCH RIVER VIA WHITE OAK CREEK
14.7 OVERALL SUMMARY OF PROJECT RESULTS
SECTION H: Evaluating Risk to Foods
15 Transport of Persistent Organic Pollutants to Animal Products: Fundamental Principles and Application to Health Risk Assessment
15.1 INTRODUCTION
15.2 ANIMAL EXPOSURE
15.3 PHARMACOKINETICS
15.4 TRANSFER COEFFICIENTS
15.5 TISSUE AND PRODUCT RELATIONSHIPS
15.6 EFFECTS OF HALOGENATION AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
15.7 DEPURATION
15.8 CASE STUDY OF A LANDFILL SITE EVALUATION
15.9 CONCLUSIONS
16 Estimating Dietary Exposure: Methods, Algorithms, and General Considerations
16.1 INTRODUCTION
16.2 SCREENING APPROACHES FOR ESTIMATING DIETARY EXPOSURE (RANGE-FINDING METHODS)
16.3 DETAILED EXPOSURE ESTIMATION METHODOLOGY
16.4 CONCLUSIONS
17 Analysis of Possible Health Risks to Recreational Fishers Due to Ingesting DDT and PCBs in Fish from Palos Verdes Shelf and Cabrillo Pier
17.1 INTRODUCTION
17.2 METHODS
17.3 RESULTS
17.4 SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY AND RESULTS
17.5 APPLICABILITY OF THE RESULTS TO OTHER POPULATIONS
17.6 DISCUSSION
17.7 CONCLUSION
SECTION I: Assessing Risks Associated with Consumer Products
18 Qualitative Health Risk Assessment of Natural Rubber Latex in Consumer Products
18.1 INTRODUCTION
18.2 FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE EXPOSURE TO ANTIGENS IN NRL GLOVES
18.3 DOSE–RESPONSE ASSESSMENT
18.4 EPIDEMIOLOGY
18.5 RISK FACTORS AND CONFOUNDERS
18.6 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
SECTION J: Case Studies in Ecological Risk Assessment
19 Determining Values: A Critical Step in Assessing Ecological Risk
19.1 INTRODUCTION
19.2 ECOLOGICALLY RELEVANT VALUES
19.3 SOCIETALLY RELEVANT VALUES
19.4 SELECTING SITE-SPECIFIC ASSESSMENT ENDPOINTS
19.5 CASE STUDY
19.6 SUMMARY
20 Comparison of Aquatic Ecological Risk Assessments at a Former Zinc Smelter and a Former Wood Preservative Site
20.1 INTRODUCTION
20.2 PROBLEM FORMULATION
20.3 EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
20.4 EFFECTS ASSESSMENT
20.5 RISK CHARACTERIZATION
20.6 COMPARATIVE RISK CHARACTERIZATION
20.7 REMEDIAL ACTIVITIES
20.8 CONCLUSION
21 Integration of Risk Assessment and Natural Resource Damage Assessment: Case Study of Lavaca Bay
21.1 INTRODUCTION
21.2 BACKGROUND ON LAVACA BAY SITE
21.3 STUDY OBJECTIVES
21.4 STUDY DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
21.5 STUDY RESULTS
21.6 DISCUSSION
SECTION K: Assessing Risks to Birds
22 Using Probabilistic Risk Assessment Methods to Predict Effects of Pesticides on Aquatic Systems and Waterfowl That Use Them
22.1 INTRODUCTION
22.2 BACKGROUND
22.3 PROBLEM FORMULATION
22.4 RISK ASSESSMENT APPROACH
22.5 EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT
22.6 EFFECTS ASSESSMENT
22.7 RISK CHARACTERIZATION
23 Methodology for Assessing Risk to Birds Following Application of Sprayable Pesticide to Citrus: Case Study Involving Chlorpyrifos
23.1 INTRODUCTION
23.2 RISK ASSESSMENT PROCESS: BRIEF HISTORY
23.3 CURRENT STATUS OF PESTICIDE RISK ASSESSMENT AT EPA
23.4 CHLORPYRIFOS USE: PHYSICAL PROPERTIES AND TOXICOLOGY
23.5 SOME IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF AVIAN FEEDING HABITS
23.6 STUDY SCOPE AND DESIGN RATIONALE
23.7 STUDY AREA
23.8 METHODS AND MATERIALS
23.9 RESULTS
23.10 DISCUSSION OF RESEARCH
23.11 AVIAN RISK ASSESSMENT: DETERMINISTIC APPROACH
23.12 OVERVIEW
24 Using Ecological Risk Assessment to Evaluate Potential Risks Posed by Chemicals to Birds
24.1 INTRODUCTION
24.2 TOOLS FOR CHARACTERIZING EXPOSURE TO BIRDS
24.3 TOOLS FOR CHARACTERIZING EFFECTS IN BIRDS
24.4 CHARACTERIZATION OF ECOLOGICAL RISKS TO BIRDS
SECTION L: Risk Assessment and Life-Cycle Analyses
25 Life-Cycle Impact Analysis: A Challenge for Risk Analysts
25.1 INTRODUCTION
25.2 INTRODUCTION TO LITE-CYCLE ASSESSMENT
25.3 ECONOMIC INPUT-OUTPUT LIFE-CYCLE ASSESSMENT
25.4 EXTERNAL COST ASSESSMENT
25.5 ARE THERE REMAINING AIR POLLUTION PROBLEMS?
25.6 TARGETING EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENTAL COSTS
25.7 TOTAL COSTS OF MANUFACTURING: DIRECT AND INDIRECT EFFECTS
25.8 EMISSIONS DATA SOURCES
25.9 DAMAGE VALUATION OF EMISSIONS
25.10 EXTERNALITIES FROM COMMODITIES: U.S. ECONOMY IN 1992
25.11 CASE STUDY OF COMPARATIVE EIO-LCA EXAMPLE: STEEL VERSUS REINFORCED CONCRETE BRIDGES
25.12 INCORPORATION OF RISK ANALYSIS INTO LIFE-CYCLE ASSESSMENT
25.13 CASE STUDY INCORPORATING HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT INTO LCA: BENZENE AIR EMISSIONS FROM AN OIL REFINERY
25.14 SUMMARY AND CONTRIBUTIONS
SECTION M: Risk Communication and Risk Management
26 Risk Assessment in Its Social Context
26.1 INTRODUCTION
26.2 USING SOCIAL SCIENCE THEORY AND PRACTICE IN RISK ASSESSMENT PROCESSES
26.3 DEFINING STAKEHOLDERS
26.4 DEFINING THE RISK PROBLEM
26.5 COMMUNICATING INFORMATION ABOUT RISK
26.6 SUMMARY
27 Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk-Assessment Battlefield
27.1 INTRODUCTION
27.2 THE SUBJECTIVE AND VALUE-LADEN NATURE OF RISK ASSESSMENT
27.3 SEX, POLITICS, AND EMOTION IN RISK JUDGMENTS
27.4 THE IMPORTANCE OF TRUST
27.5 RESOLVING RISK CONFLICTS: WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?
28 Democratization of Risk Analysis
28.1 INTRODUCTION
28.2 RISK ANALYSIS AND THE LAW
28.3 SCHOLARLY CRITIQUES OF RISK ANALYSIS
28.4 REGULATORY RISK ANALYSIS
28.5 DEMOCRATIC DECISION MAKING: CASE EXAMPLES
28.6 CONCLUSION: SCIENCE AND DEMOCRACY
29 Misconceptions About the Causes of Cancer
SECTION N: Evolving Issues
30 Children’s Health and Environmental Exposure to Chemicals: Implications for Risk Assessment and Public Health Policy
30.1 INTRODUCTION
30.2 CHRONOLOGY OF REGULATORY EVENTS: 1988–2000
30.3 DIFFERENCES IN EXPOSURE AND RESPONSE TO TOXIC AGENTS BETWEEN CHILDREN AND ADULTS
30.4 SELECTED ENVIRONMENTAL CHILDREN’S HEALTH ISSUES
30.5 CHILDHOOD CANCER
30.6 DEVELOPMENTAL DEFECTS
30.7 CHILDHOOD ASTHMA
30.8 CONCLUSIONS
31 Cost–Benefit Analysis
31.1 INTRODUCTION TO COST–BENEFIT ANALYSIS
31.2 BACKGROUND OF CASE STUDY
31.3 SOCIETAL PERSPECTIVE
31.4 ANALYTIC TIME HORIZON
31.5 BASELINE ESTIMATES OF RISK
31.6 DECISION OPTIONS
31.7 OPPORTUNITY COST ESTIMATION
31.8 VALUATION OF IMPROVEMENTS IN HUMAN HEALTH
31.9 DISCOUNTING FUTURE BENEFITS AND COSTS
31.10 UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS
31.11 INTANGIBLE AND NONQUANTIFIABLE BENEFITS AND COSTS
31.12 CONCLUSION
32 Precaution in a Multirisk World
32.1 BACKGROUND
32.2 RISK AND UNCERTAINTY
32.3 PRECAUTION AS A PRINCIPLE
32.4 PRECAUTION AMIDST MULTIPLE RISKS
32.5 PRECAUTION AS APPLIED
32.6 CONCLUSIONS
INDEX
End User License Agreement
List of Tables
1 Primer on Human and Environmental Risk Assessment
TABLE 1.1 An Historical Timeline of Events Having Some Significance on the Evolution of the Environmental Movement (based on information in http://www.zoaks.com/information/envirotimeline/envirotimeline.html)
TABLE 1.2 Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic (PB-PK) Models for Environmental Toxicants
2 Hazard Identification
TABLE 2.1 Criteria Often Used in Hazard Identification
TABLE 2.2 Categorization of Evidence of Carcinogenocity Used by EPA from 1986 to 1996 (EPA, 1986)
TABLE 2.3 IARC Classification of Chemical Carcinogens (IARC, 1999)
TABLE 2.4 Weight of Evidence Classification Methods for Developmental Effects; A Noncancer Effect (EPA, 1986)
TABLE 2.5 Standard Descriptors (formerly known as categories or classifications) Proposed by EPA in 1999 for Chemicals with Carcinogenic Potential (EPA, 1999)
TABLE 2.6 Candidate Tests for Screening Ecological Impact of New Products
TABLE 2.7 Environmental Processes and Properties That Influence the Degree of Hazard
TABLE 2.8 Solubilities and Partition Coefficients of Various Compounds
TABLE 2.9 Water Solubilities of Various Halogenated Aliphatic Hydrocarbons
TABLE 2.10 Water Solubilities of Various Pesticides
TABLE 2.11 Vapor Pressure and Volatilization Half-Life of Various Halogenated Aliphatic Hydrocarbons
TABLE 2.12 Equilibrium Vapor Pressure and Vapor Density at 30°C
TABLE 2.13 Water Solubility, Soil Adsorption Coefficient, and Bioconcentration Factor Data: Experimental and Calculated
TABLE 2.14 Solubilities and Partition Coefficients of Various Compounds
TABLE 2.15 Partition Coefficients (
K
o/w
) of Various Chemicals
TABLE 2.16 Methods for Estimating the Bioconcentration Factor (BCF) Using Physical Property Data
TABLE 2.17 Log BCF and Bioconcentration Potential (DDE = 100) for 30 Organic Chemicals as Determined with the Fathead Minnow in 32-day Exposures
TABLE 2.18 Terminology Useful in Understanding Behavior of Chemicals in Aquatic Systems
TABLE 2.19 Bioconcentration of Kepone from Water by Estuarine Organisms
TABLE 2.20 Hydrolysis Rates (Half-Life) at pH 7.4
TABLE 2.21 Test Species Commonly Used for Freshwater Toxicity Tests
4 Exposure Assessment
TABLE 4.1 Types of Biological Sampling Used to Characterize Exposure-Related Media and Parameters
TABLE 4.2 Some Standard Assumptions Used In Regulatory Assessments (EPA, 1996)
TABLE 4.3 Human Cutaneous Permeability Coefficient Values for Some Industrial Chemicals in Aqueous Medium
TABLE 4.4 Representative Surface Areas of the Human Body (Adult Male)
TABLE 4.5 Absorption Rates of Some Neat Industrial Liquid Chemicals in Human Skin In Vivo
TABLE 4.6 Percutaneous Absorption Rates for Chemical Vapors In Vivo
TABLE 4.7 Summary of Tap-water Intake by Age
TABLE 4.8 Values for Childhood and Adult Soil Ingestion Rates That Have Been Used in Health Risk Assessments Conducted Between 1984 and 2000
TABLE 4.9 Summary of Default Exposure Factor Recommendations and Confidence Ratings for Citizens of United States (EPA, 1997)
TABLE 4.10 Default Values for Daily Intakes of Breast Milk
TABLE 4.11 Daily Inhalation Rates Estimated From Daily Activities
TABLE 4.12 U.S. EPA Guiding Principles for Monte Carlo Analysis
TABLE 4.13 Risks Calculated for Exposure to Four Halogenated Solvents in Water Using Probabilistic Analysis at the MCL Level and for the 50th and 95th Percentile Exposure
TABLE 4.14 Results of Sensitivity Analysis for Tetrachloroethylene Exposure in Household Water
TABLE 4.15 Effect of Matrix and Aging on the Bioavailability of Lead from Soil
TABLE 4.16 Biomarkers Examined for Selected Occupational and Environmental Chemicals
5 Risk Characterization
TABLE 5.1 Key Components of Risk Characterization for Hazard Identification
TABLE 5.2 Key Components of Risk Characterization for Exposure Assessment
TABLE 5.3 Key Components of Risk Characterization for dose–response Relationship
TABLE 5.4 Types of Uncertainty in Risk Characterization
TABLE 5.5 Traditional EPA Classification System for Carcinogens
TABLE 5.6 Median of Cost/Life-Year Saved Estimates as a Function of Sector of Society and Type of Intervention
TABLE 5.7 Maximum Plausible Excess Cancer Risk for Persons at a Residential Site
TABLE 5.8 Maximum Plausible Excess Cancer Risk for Workers Exposed at an Industrial Site
TABLE 5.9 Estimated Hazard Quotients (HQs) and Hazard Index (HI) for Californians Exposed to MTBE in Drinking Water
TABLE 5.10 Age-Specific Margin of Safety (MOS) for the Noncarcinogenic Hazard to the Maximally Exposed Individual (MEI) and Most Likely Exposed Individual (MLEI) at a Residential Site
TABLE 5.11 Distribution of Margin of Safety (MOS) for Noncarcinogenic Hazard for Workers at an Industrial Site
TABLE 5.12 In Vivo Percutaneous Absorption of Chemicals in Humans and Animals
TABLE 5.13 Formaldehyde Risk Estimate for Rats Based on Alternative Mathematical Models (Excess Lifetime Cancers per 100,000)
6 Ecological Risk Assessment: History and Fundamentals
TABLE 6.1 Flexibility of the Framework Diagram
TABLE 6.2 Who Are Risk Managers?
TABLE 6.3 Who Are Risk Assessors?
TABLE 6.4 Who Are Interested and Affected Parties?
TABLE 6.5 Tiers and Iteration: When Is a Risk Assessment Done?
TABLE 6.6 Questions to Ask About Scope and Complexity
TABLE 6.7 Questions to Ask About Source, Stressor, and Exposure Characteristics, Ecosystem Characteristics, and Effects [derived in part from Barnthouse and Brown, (1994)]
TABLE 6.8 Salmon and Hydropower: Salmon as the Basis for an Assessment Endpoint
TABLE 6.9 Sensitivity and Secondary Effects: The Mussels and Fish
TABLE 6.10 Examples of Management Goals and Assessment Endpoints
TABLE 6.11 Benefits of Conceptual Models
TABLE 6.12 Examples of Risk Questions
TABLE 6.13 Examples of a Management Goal, Assessment Endpoint, and Measures
TABLE 6.14 Evaluating a Study for Usefulness in ERA
TABLE 6.15 Considering the Degree of Aggregation in Models
TABLE 6.16 Questions for Source Description
TABLE 6.17 Additional Questions for Introduction of Biological Stressors
TABLE 6.18 General Mechanisms of Transport and Dispersal
TABLE 6.19 Questions To Ask in Describing Contact or Co-Occurrence
TABLE 6.20 Example of an Exposure Equation: Calculating a Potential Dose via Ingestion
TABLE 6.21 Exposure Profile Questions
TABLE 6.22 Questions for Stressor–Response Analysis Questions
TABLE 6.23 Qualitative Stressor–Response Relationships
TABLE 6.24 Median Effect Levels
TABLE 6.25 No-Effect Levels Derived from Statistical Hypothesis Testing
TABLE 6.26 General Criteria for Causality [Adapted from Fox, (1991)]
TABLE 6.27 Koch’s Postulates (Pelczar and Reid, 1972)
TABLE 6.28 Examples of Extrapolations to Link Measures of Effect to Assessment Endpoints
TABLE 6.29 Questions Related to Selecting Extrapolation Approaches
TABLE 6.30 Questions to Consider When Extrapolating from Effects Observed in the Laboratory to Field Effects of Chemicals
TABLE 6.31 Questions Addressed by the Stressor–Response Profile
TABLE 6.32 Example of Field Methods Used for Risk Estimation
TABLE 6.33 Using Qualitative Categories to Estimate Risks of an Introduced Species
TABLE 6.34 Applying the Quotient Method
TABLE 6.35 Comparing an Exposure Distribution with a Point Estimate of Effects
TABLE 6.36 Comparing Cumulative Exposure and Effects Distributions for Chemical Stressors
TABLE 6.37 What Are Statistically Significant Effects?
TABLE 6.38 Possible Risk Assessment Report Elements
TABLE 6.39 Clear, Transparent, Reasonable, and Consistent Risk Characterizations
TABLE 6.40 Questions Regarding Risk Assessment Results
TABLE 6.41 Suggestions for Successful Risk Communication
7 Hexavalent Chromium in Groundwater: The Importance of Chemistry and Pharmacokinetics in Quantitating Dose and Risk
TABLE 7.1 Partial List of Illnesses or Complaints that Plaintiffs from Various Legal Actions have Claimed to be Possibly Caused by Exposure to Cr(VI)
TABLE 7.2 Summary of Key Studies Documenting No Observable Adverse Effect Levels (NOAEL) for Oral Cr(VI) Exposure in Animals and Humans
TABLE 7.3 Summary of Key Studies Documenting No Effect or Low Effect Levels for Inhalation Cr(VI) Exposures in Animals and Humans
TABLE 7.4 Summary of Human Volunteer Studies Involving Ingestion of Water-Soluble Chromium Compounds
TABLE 7.5 Possible Sources of Exposure to Contaminated Water
TABLE 7.6 Calculation Methods when Conducting Individual-Specific Cr(VI) Assessments
8 Estimating the Value of Research: Illustrative Calculation for Ingested Inorganic Arsenic
TABLE 8.1 Low-Dose Risks for Arsenic Ingestion
TABLE 8.2 Drinking Water Exposure Assumptions
TABLE 8.3 Exposure Assumptions for Inorganic Arsenic in Food
TABLE 8.4 Annual Costs and Benefits of Reducing the Arsenic Drinking Water Standard from 50 to 20 μg/L
TABLE 8.5 Effect of Alternative Prior Probabilities on Value of Information
TABLE 8.6 Effect of Reducing Uncertainty Regarding one Issue on Value of Information from Other Research
9 Risk Assessment of Chromium-Contaminated Soils: Twelve Years of Research to Characterize the Health Hazards
TABLE 9.1 Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Chromite Ore Processing Residue (COPR)
TABLE 9.2 Modifications to Extraction and Analysis Methods for Cr(VI) in Solid Matrices
TABLE 9.3 Exposure Scenarios and Pathways Typically Considered at Chromite Ore Processing Residue (COPR) Sites in Kearny, NJ
TABLE 9.4 Evaluation of Oxidation Potential of Trivalent Chromium Present in Chromite Ore Processing Residue (COPR)
TABLE 9.5 Mean Daily Spot Urine Chromium Concentrations
TABLE 9.6 Hexavalent and Trivalent Chromium Toxicity Criteria Used in Chromite Ore Processing Residue (COPR) Risk Assessments
TABLE 9.7 Alternative Remediation Standards (ARSs) for Special Remedial Organization-Managed Sites
10 Quantification of Variability and Uncertainty: Case Study of Power Plant Hazardous Air Pollutant Emissions
TABLE 10.1 Expressions for Log-Likelihood Functions for Data Belonging to Various Probability Distribution Models
TABLE 10.2 Summary of Data Sets and Fitted Distributions for Variability in the Concentration of Hazardous Air Pollutant in Bituminous Coal
TABLE 10.3 Summary of Data Sets and Fitted Distributions for Variability in the Partitioning of Hazardous Air Pollutant in Dry-Bottom Wall-Fired Boilers
TABLE 10.4 Summary of Data Sets and Fitted Distributions for Variability in the Partitioning of Hazardous Air Pollutant in Fabric Filters
11 Characteristic Time, Characteristic Travel Distance, and Population-Based Potential Dose in a Multimedia Environment: A Case Study
TABLE 11.1 List of Transfer Pathways in Multimedia Model
TABLE 11.2 Representative Spatially Averaged Landscape Properties
TABLE 11.3 List of Exposure Pathways
TABLE 11.4 Representative Population Densities and Areas
TABLE 11.5 Representative Chemical Properties Used in the Case Study
TABLE 11.6 Fugacity, Inventory, Concentration, and Mass Transformed for Each Compartment for a Fixed Region Using TCDD
12 Methods for Setting Occupational Exposure Limits
TABLE 12.1 Body Weight and Inhalation Rates of Average Human Adult
TABLE 12.2 Some Adjustment Factors Occasionally Used to Derive Occupational Exposure Limits
13 Worker Hazard Posed by Reentry into Pesticide-Treated Foliage: Reassessment of Reentry Levels/Intervals Using Foliar Residue Transfer–Percutaneous Absorption PBPK/PD Models, with Emphasis on Isofenphos and Parathion
TABLE 13.1 Summary of Repeated Dose and Subchronic Toxicity Data for Parathion
TABLE 13.2 Summary of Repeated Dose and Subchronic Toxicity Data for Isofenphos
TABLE 13.3 Reentry Intervals (REI) for Parathion Applied to Citrus at 10 lb AI/acre
TABLE 13.4 Calculation of Reentry Intervals According to U.S. EPA
10
Guidelines with Slight Modification
TABLE 13.5 Dermal Dose–ChE Response Expressed in Terms of Total Body Surface, Body Weight, and Safety Index
TABLE 13.6 Establishment of Safe Levels on Tree Foliage (in μg/cm
2
) Using the Results of Dermal Dose–ChE Response Studies in Male Rats and Field Reentry Studies
TABLE 13.7 Procedure for Establishing Safe Levels (μg/cm
2
) for Thions + Oxons on Tree Foliage
TABLE 13.8 Parameters Used in the Physiologically Based Pharmacokinetic Models
TABLE 13.9 Partition Coefficients Used in the Isofenphos Model
TABLE 13.10 Partition Coefficients Used in the Parathion Model
TABLE 13.11
V
max
,
K
m
Values Used in Percutaneous Absorption Route, Isofenphos
TABLE 13.12
V
max
,
K
m
Values Used in Percutaneous Absorption Route, Parathion
TABLE 13.13 Tissue AChE, BChE, and ChE
TABLE 13.14 Affinity Constants (
K
a
) and Phosphorylation Constants (
k
p
) Used to Describe the Inhibition of Tissue AChE, BChE, and CaE by des N-isopropyl Isofenphos Oxon in the Rat and Human
TABLE 13.15 Affinity Constants (
K
a
) and Phosphorylation Constants (
k
p
) Used to Describe the Inhibition of Tissue AChE, BChE, and CaE by Paraoxon in the Rat and Human
TABLE 13.16 Fate of
14
C-ring Labeled Isofenphos and Parathion Topically Administered to the Rat in Percent of Dose
TABLE 13.17 Percentage of Enzyme Inhibited by Topical Application of Isofenphos or Parathion to the Skin of Rats
TABLE 13.18 Fate of Isofenphos and Parathion Topically Administered to the Human in Percent of Dose (Output from Models)
TABLE 13.19 Percentage of Enzymes Inhibited by Topical Application of Isofenphos or Parathion to the Skin of the Human (Models)
TABLE 13.20 Percentage of Enzymes Inhibited by Transfer of Parathion Leaf Residues to Skin of Workers
TABLE 13.21 Percentage of Enzymes Inhibited by Transfer of Isofenphos Turf Residues to Skin of Workers
14 Dose Reconstructions for Radionuclides and Chemicals: Case Study Involving Federal Facilities at Oak Ridge, Tennessee
TABLE 14.1 Estimated Annual Iodine-131 Releases from Oak Ridge Radioactive Lanthanum Processing
TABLE 14.2 Excess Lifetime Risks of Incurring Thyroid Cancer for Females Born in Gailaher Bend Area near Oak Ridge, TN, in 1952, Lived There through 1956, and Ate Various Diets That Included Locally Produced Foods
TABLE 14.3 Toxicity Benchmarks for Comparison with Results of Oak Ridge Mercury Dose Reconstruction
TABLE 14.4 Summary of Cancer Risks Evaluated in Level II Analysis of PCBs in Environment near Oak Ridge
TABLE 14.5 Summary of Noncancer Risks (Hazard Quotients) Evaluated in Level II Analysis of PCBs in Environment near Oak Ridge
TABLE 14.6 Estimates of True Hazard Quotients for Adult Recreational and Commercial Fish Consumers Evaluated in Level III Analysis of PCBs in Environment Near Oak Ridge
TABLE 14.7 Percentages of Fish-Consuming Populations Receiving a PCB Dose Above the Population Threshold Estimated in the Oak Ridge Dose Reconstruction
TABLE 14.8 Summary of Peak Annual Releases for Eight Key Radionuclides Evaluated in Dose Reconstruction for Releases to Clinch River via White Oak Creek
TABLE 14.9 Historical Airborne Uranium Release Totals (kg) for Oak Ridge Y-12 Plant and K-25/S-50 Plants Estimated in Oak Ridge Health Studies and Reported by DOE for Same Facilities
TABLE 14.10 Summary of Screening Indices from Oak Ridge Health Studies Evaluation of Past Uranium Releases
TABLE 14.11 Categorization of Potential Materials of Concern Based on Screening Conducted During Oak Ridge Health Studies
15 Transport of Persistent Organic Pollutants to Animal Products: Fundamental Principles and Application to Health Risk Assessment
TABLE 15.1 Physiological and Residue Measurements Required for Calculation Transfer Coefficients
TABLE 15.2 Summary of Median Carryover Ratios (COR), Bioconcentration Factors (BCF), and Biotransfer Factors (BTFs) for PCDD/Fs from Diet to Milk in Dairy Cows
TABLE 15.3 Predicted Concentrations of PCDDs and PCDFs in Dry Matter of Soil and Feeds Produced at Property Boundary of Proposed Waste-Handling Facility
TABLE 15.4 Predicted Concentrations of PCDDs and PCDFs in Fat of Beef and Milk Produced by Cattle at Property Boundary of Proposed Waste-Handling Facility
17 Analysis of Possible Health Risks to Recreational Fishers Due to Ingesting DDT and PCBs in Fish from Palos Verdes Shelf and Cabrillo Pier
TABLE 17.1 Comparison of Three Different Methods to Depict Four Different Exposure Assessment Elements
TABLE 17.2 Fish Species and Species Groups Included in the Analyses
TABLE 17.3 Distribution Functions for Various Exposure Factors Used in the Commercial Passenger Fishing Vessel (CPFV) Analysis
TABLE 17.4 Distribution Functions for Various Exposure Factors Used in the Private Boat Analysis
TABLE 17.5 Distribution Functions for Various Exposure Factors Used in the Cabrillo Pier Analysis
TABLE 17.6 Lifetime Exposure Factors for Monte Carlo Analysis
TABLE 17.7 Annual Exposure Factors for Monte Carlo Analysis
TABLE 17.8 Trip-Specific Exposure Factors for Monte Carlo Analysis
TABLE 17.9 Results of the Analysis for Commercial Passenger Fishing Vessel (CPFV) Anglers at the Palos Verdes Shelf
TABLE 17.10 Results of the Analysis for Private Boat Anglers at the Palos Verdes Shelf
TABLE 17.11 Results of the Analysis for Anglers at Cabrillo Pier
TABLE 17.12 Description of the Approach for Conducting the Sensitivity Analyses
TABLE 17.13 Alternative Distributions for tDDT and PCB Concentrations in White Croaker at Cabrillo Pier
TABLE 17.14 Sensitivity Analysis Results for Cancer Risks for Commercial Passenger Fishing Vessel (CPFV) Anglers
TABLE 17.15 Sensitivity Analysis Results for Noncancer Hazards for Commercial Passenger Fishing Vessel (CPFV) Anglers
TABLE 17.16 Sensitivity Analysis Results for Cancer Risks for Cabrillo Pier Anglers
TABLE 17.17 Sensitivity Analysis Results for Noncancer Hazards for Cabrillo Pier Anglers
TABLE 17.18 Profiles of CPFV Anglers with Total Risks at the 50th Percentile (Total Risk = 5 × 10
−8
)
TABLE 17.19 Profiles of CPFV Anglers with Total Risks at the 95th Percentile (Total Risk = 8 × 10
−7
)
TABLE 17.20 Profiles of Simulated Private Boat Anglers with Total Risks at the 50th Percentile (Total Risk = 3 × 10
−7
)
TABLE 17.21 Profiles of Simulated Private Boat Anglers with Total Risks at the 95th Percentile (Total Risk = 3 × 10
−6
)
TABLE 17.22 Profiles of Cabrillo Pier Anglers with Total Risks at the 50th Percentile (Total Risk = 2 × 10
−7
)
TABLE 17.23 Profiles of Cabrillo Pier Anglers with Total Risks at the 95th Percentile (Total Risk = 3 × 10
−6
)
TABLE 17.24 Comparison of Risk Estimates and Exposure Factor Values from Risk Assessments for Palos Verdes Shelf Fish Consumers
TABLE 17.25 Comparison of Risk Estimates and Exposure Factor Values from Risk Assessments for Cabrillo Pier Fish Consumers
18 Qualitative Health Risk Assessment of Natural Rubber Latex in Consumer Products
TABLE 18.1 Comparison of Reported vs. Actual Incidences of NRL Allergy in Health-Care Workers
TABLE 18.2 Summary of Selected Studies Reporting Latex Allergy Incidence in Health-Care Workers
TABLE 18.3 Estimates of Background NRL Allergy Incidence in the General Population
TABLE 18.4 Summary of Studies That Meet Minimum Design Criteria
19 Determining Values: A Critical Step in Assessing Ecological Risk
TABLE 19.1 Functional Components of a Tropical Rain Forest Ecosystem in New Guinea
TABLE 19.2 Ecologically Relevant Attributes of the Functional Components Identified for a Tropical Rain Forest Ecosystem in New Guinea
TABLE 19.3 Functional Components of the Food Webs for Three General Ecosystem Types
TABLE 19.4 Representative Organisms for Each of the Functional Components of the Pajarito Plateau Ecosystem
20 Comparison of Aquatic Ecological Risk Assessments at a Former Zinc Smelter and a Former Wood Preservative Site
TABLE 20.1 Endpoints and Risk Characterization Approach for Aquatic Ecological Risk Assessment
TABLE 20.2 Summary of Toxicity Results for
Ceriodaphnia
Test
TABLE 20.3 Relative Abundances of Fishes Captured at Site and Reference Areas by Species
TABLE 20.4 Relative Abundances of Fishes Captured at Site Stations and Reference Areas in Percentages
TABLE 20.5 Comparison of Sediment Quality Values (SQVs) (mg/kg)
TABLE 20.6 Comparison of Elements of Ecological Risk Assessments at Former Zinc Smelter Site and Former Wood Preservative Site
21 Integration of Risk Assessment and Natural Resource Damage Assessment: Case Study of Lavaca Bay
TABLE 21.1 Summary of Data Needs from Recreational Anglers
TABLE 21.2 Results of Texas Saltwater Fish Survey: Grams per Day of Self-Caught Fish Consumed
TABLE 21.3 Summary of Consumption Studies of Marine Recreational Anglers
TABLE 21.4 Species Composition of Self-Caught Fish Consumed by Source
22 Using Probabilistic Risk Assessment Methods to Predict Effects of Pesticides on Aquatic Systems and Waterfowl That Use Them
TABLE 22.1 Invertebrate Taxa Commonly Found in Prairie Sloughs
TABLE 22.2 Macroinvertebrate Prey Selected by Flightless Ducklings Foraging in Prairie Pothole Region
TABLE 22.3 Summary Statistics for Application Rates
TABLE 22.4 Characteristics of Application Efficiency Distribution
TABLE 22.5 Depth and Permanency of Water Body Types
TABLE 22.6 Summary Statistics for Water Column Concentrations
TABLE 22.7 Summary of Toxicity Data for Carbaryl
TABLE 22.8 Summary of Laboratory Studies of Toxicity of Deltamethrin and Cypermethrin
TABLE 22.9 Estimated l ethal Concentrations (µg/L) for Percentages of Aquatic Species Populations Exposed to Carbaryl in Laboratory Toxicity Tests
TABLE 22.10 Estimated Concentrations (µg/L) Lethal to Percentage of Population of Aquatic Species Exposed to Deltamethrin in
23 Methodology for Assessing Risk to Birds Following Application of Sprayable Pesticide to Citrus: Case Study Involving Chlorpyrifos
TABLE 23.1 Physical and Chemical Properties of Chlorpyrifos
TABLE 23.2 Laboratory Acute Oral Toxicity (LD
50
) Values for Chlorpyrifos to Various Bird Species
TABLE 23.3 Laboratory Acute Dietary Toxicity (LC
50
) Values for Chlorpyrifos to Various Bird Species
TABLE 23.4 Summary of Samples Collected from Study Plots during EBA Study Number 079717 Conducted at Harlan Ranch in Clovis, CA, July 1997
TABLE 23.5 Measured and Corrected Residue Means, Standard Deviations, and Geometric Means for Samples Collected from Study Plots at Harlan Ranch Near Clovis, CA, July 1997
TABLE 23.6 Pinned Larvae and Cricket Residues Normalized to Initial Body Weights
TABLE 23.7 One-Time Consumption
a
of Food Types Used and Required for Individual to Attain LD
50
If Consumption Occurred at Time of Peak Residues
TABLE 23.8 Risk Quotients Derived from Environmental Concentrations on Food Items Measured Divided by Reported LC
50
Values for Various Bird Species
25 Life-Cycle Impact Analysis: A Challenge for Risk Analysts
TABLE 25.1 EIO-LCA Supply Chain Effects of Producing $1 Million of Electricity in United States, 1992
TABLE 25.2 Top Ten Contributing Sectors to Conventional Pollutant and Global Warming Releases Associated with Producing $1 Million of Electricity in United States
TABLE 25.3 Total U.S. Emissions and Estimated External Costs of Various Pollutants, 1992
TABLE 25.4 Ten Commodity Sectors with Largest PM Emissions
TABLE 25.5 Social Damages per Metric Ton of Sulfur Dioxide Air Emissions
TABLE 25.6 Unit Social Damage Estimates from Air Emissions of Environmental Externalities
TABLE 25.7 Estimated External Air Pollution Damage from $100,000 of Production (in dollars) from Eight Sample Commodity Sectors
TABLE 25.8 Ten Commodity Sectors with Highest External Air Pollution Cost Percentages in U.S. Economy, 1992
TABLE 25.9 Ten Commodity Sectors with Highest Total External Air Pollution Costs in U.S. Economy, 1992
TABLE 25.10 Top Purchases Associated with $100 Million of Demand for Eating-and-Drinking Establishments
TABLE 25.11 Top Contributing External Cost Sectors Associated with $100 Million of Output from Eating and Drinking Establishments (in millions of dollars.)
TABLE 25.12 Low Bids for U.S. 231 over the White River in Indiana
TABLE 25.13 Environmental Effects of Steel-Reinforced Concrete (Concrete + Reinforcing) and Steel Production for an Example Equivalent Bridge Girder Design: Summary of Resource Inputs
TABLE 25.14 Environmental Effects of Steel-Reinforced Concrete (Concrete + Reinforcing) and Steel Production for Example Equivalent Bridge Girder Design: Summary of Environmental Outputs
TABLE 25.15 Environmental Effects of Paint (for Eight Repaint Jobs) and Steel Manufacturing for a Typical Highway Bridge: Summary of Resource Inputs
TABLE 25.16 Environmental Effects of Paint (for Eight Repaint Jobs) and Steel Manufacturing for Typical Highway Bridge: Summary of Environmental Outputs
TABLE 25.17 Resource Inputs for Manufacturing Steel Girders for 290,000 “Average” Bridges as Percentage of Annual National Totals (U.S.)
TABLE 25.18 Environmental Outputs for Manufacturing Steel Girders for 290,000 “Average” Bridges as Percentage of Annual National Totals (U.S.)
TABLE 25.19 Summary of Environmental Impact of Steel versus Steel-Reinforced Concrete Girders for Typical Highway Bridge
TABLE 25.20 Facility Data: SUN Company, Philadelphia Refinery
TABLE 25.21 Facility and Atmospheric Information, Sun Company
TABLE 25.22 Threshold Values of Noncarcinogenic and Acute Health Risks
TABLE 25.23 Benzene Concentrations for Accident and Chronic Emissions
TABLE 25.24 Lifetime Individual Risk
TABLE 25.25 AIRS Reporting Threshold Requirements for Facilities: Criteria Pollutant Emission (short tons/year)
TABLE 25.26 Summary of Adjustments Made Based on Emissions Trends Report Data
27 Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk-Assessment Battlefield
TABLE 27.1 Some Ways of Expressing Mortality Risks
TABLE 27.2 Percentage of People Who Agreed to Support a New Nuclear Power Plant in Their Community
29 Misconceptions About the Causes of Cancer
TABLE 29.1 Review of Epidemiological Studies on Cancer Showing Protection by Consumption of Fruits and Vegetables
TABLE 29.2 Carcinogenicity Status of Natural Pesticides Tested in Rodents
TABLE 29.3 Carcinogenicity in Rodents of Natural Chemicals in Roasted Coffee
TABLE 29.4 Proportion of Chemicals Evaluated as Carcinogenic
TABLE 29.5 Cancer Risk Assessment Without Conducting a 2-Year Bioassay
TABLE 29.6 Ranking Possible Carcinogenic Hazards from Average U.S. Exposures to Rodent Carcinogens